what is buspar side effects avalide reviews for men zovirax reviews for men how long does it take for cymbalta to reduce pain free viagra sample pack free sexual side effects of lexapro vs celexa snovitra super power online cheap what is the medicine prednisolone for prescription free generic paxil tadacip erectalis 20 mg tabletten prevacid prices at costco buy feldene online in usa compazine online in usa masters in clinical pharmacy in canada benzac weight gain anxiety medication when pregnant where to get ortho tri-cyclen lo doxycycline hyclate 20 mg acne haldol in australia buy fucidin tablets online cheap kamagra oral jelly australia diamox tablets on line to buy actonel plus calcium d 35mg+1000mg/880i.e cheap atorlip-20 no prescription buy cheap crestor cod finax drugstore.com cardizem 10 mg iv what is doryx capsules used for how much does children;s motrin cost do you need rx arimidex uesp meridia;s beacon prograf sales us motilium 10 mg tabletta desyrel 40mg tetracycline capsules b.p buy lopressor from mexico online long term use of zyrtec side effects can mylan a1 get you high buy canadiani drugs without a prescription how to take live band photos can you buy xbox live time with microsoft points can you only get eurax on prescription clavamox cats without prescription femcare italiano tricor drug oversea propecia vs finasteride 5 mg accutane 60 mg per day buy generic torsemide online with prescription donde puedo comprar pulseras livestrong en mexico wellbutrin cost canadian buy benicar 80 mg online emsam drug schedule buspar delivery uk vantin online toprol side effects hair loss low cost overnight acai buy canada no prescription for pyridium low cost vermox diurex water pills acne order renagel online no prescription with a amex how much will sustiva cost walmart pharmacy singulair generic where to buy valtrex over the counter aripiprazole generic india tetracycline resistance concentration buy generic ortho tri cyclen online with prescription aceon drug class cheap atorlip-5 uk ivermectin 12 mg albendazole 400 mg donde puedo comprar flomax online sale of serophene how to get off cymbalta safely by james harper ciprofloxacin wikip can you buy retin over the counter is mail order betoptic safe is generic zestril effective ventolin uk brand name can you get high off cozaar can premarin cause weight gain craigslist edinburgh all personals where can i get acticin pills generic viagra sildenafil 100mg tetracycline manufacturer in india buying probalan using paypal indian allies american revolution flomax commercial youtube wellbutrin shoppers drug mart original aricept online where to get zantac for babies buy elimite fast shipping viagra price list in indian rupees buy rumalaya liniment bulk micardis online in usa buy cheap accutane online order isoniazid online legally cvs propecia price buy diovan for daily use asacol sales robaxin tablets package insert current gold price live update non prescription eulexin pharmacy generic cialis us pharmacy medrol drug schedule strattera sleeping pills comprar clonidine pela internet side effects of provera while pregnant where to get pletal pct side effects of taking prilosec long term atrovent on line purchase zithromax azithromycin 250 mg craigslist london uk housing floxin where to purchase probalan order canada femara medication side effects discount pharmacy toronto actos dosage forms cheap diclofenac gel india mexican pharmacy online oxycodone acheter viagra generique pas cher best place to buy cheap viagra revatio now neurontin available over counter how to use insulin pen midamor uses medication purchase citalopram insurance agent jobs cialis trial packs zovirax ointment dosage can you order buy toprol xl online what is depakote er 500mg parlodel results forum kamagra oral jelly forums styplon drugstore.com what are the most common side effects of effexor xr is mail order ceftin safe online uk cheap nizoral best site to buy apcalis sx can you buy paypal cheap haridra list three types of drugs albendazole side effects in children acyclovir no prescription real viagra sale online buy abortion pills online india requip western australia can you open lithium capsules getting viagra prescription online where can i buy alliums comprar cialis original en andorra without a script buy abilify buy maxaman hong kong alli online printable coupon rogaine uk online metformin where to purchase zetia prescription list of anti anxiety drugs buy femcare inhaler canada amoxil how much will levitra plus cost rhinocort dosering safe to buy generic femara from uk can aricept tablets be crushed buy vpxl online no prescription us motilium 10mg domperidone janssen-cilag zofran generic cost buy lanoxin boots pharmacy fucidin over counter canada claritin ingredients tablets imuran film tablet 50 mg 100 tb amoxil no prescription uroxatral non perscription countries rumalaya forte delivery duphalac generic 2013 drugs is dulcolax an over the counter drug elimite with american express clonidine medication cost medrol prescription meclizine pharmacy coupons antabuse on line for sale no script what drug category is pamelor singulair online montelukast maxaman paypal goes you buy diflucan pharmacy cheap does alli work uk generic biaxin usa pharmacy zithromax reviews side effects premarin usa sale buy metformin uk fast dulcolax deleviery buy altace mexican pharmacies synthroid where to buy most common side effects of cipro donde comprar roacutan en mexico synthroid dosage too high symptoms trazodone next-day drowsiness where can i get wellbutrin pills amantadine overdose dogs hydrochlorothiazide online forum why has malegra dxt been discontinued buy combivent online from usa zyloprim order on web non prescription extendaquin what are the long term side effects of aciphex lopressor pharmacy coupons albenza order in the us suprax suspension coupons current price clomid paroxetine hcl 20 mg side effects valacyclovir dosage shingles top 10 online azulfidine sites ordering artane viagra approved by fda aspirin dose migraine without altace online buy cheap licensed pharmacy toradol buy tadalis sx online from usa bupropion hcl side effects weight gain buy reminyl online usa metoclopramide uses medication how do you get a prescription for propecia lisinopril sold over counter purchase orlistat 60mg clomid non perscription countries comprar effexor xr original en madrid coreg looking for buy sarafem patch lotrisone pills sweat order prescription drugs from india where to buy celadrin cream in canada cafergot 20mg tab the best online pharmacy reviews imitrex without prescription miami bupropion pharmacy order what diseases does prednisone treat clomiphene challenge fertility test generic soft tabs viagra prograf perth australia lowest price colchicine buy lexapro next day dramamine for men in usa moduretic medicine online zentel worm medicine for kids normal dose of hyzaar cheap generic ampicillin maximum safe dosage of levitra imitrex australia cost levaquin 750 mg walmart diclofenaco sodico gel topico 1 amantadine mg buy where can i get generic allegra-d phone in order for cialis super active aspirin uk brand name fluoxetine shop tadacip on line no script apcalis sx prix en pharmacie en france cheap genuine lynoral online is there a drug comparative to zebeta phenergan drug in fr pharmacy canadian pharmacy vipps approved best site get retino-a cream 0,025 prevacid shortage recall finasteride for hair loss over the counter buy diclofenac gel without a script shallaki pharmacy order betapace cheap uk eldepryl mail order furosemide online purchase buy cefadroxil xr without prescription strattera prices cvs wellbutrin from zoloft topamax and sleeping pills speman cost comparison is metformin better than clomid how to order septra cheapest cymbalta to buy canadian alliance of physiotherapy provincial clozapine order form cheap generic anafranil buy abilify 50 bystolic canada prescription clomiphene citrate for men infertility can you get diltiazem over the counter can you buy arjuna generic cheap doxycycline dosage for lymes disease can you get addicted to singulair canadiapharmacy.viagra glucotrol xl woldwide shipping prednisone 5mg treat furosemide 500mg tablet do i need a prescription for cialis in canada best place buy eurax when was celebrex approved in canada silagra online order can you get pregnant on bactrim long time side effects yasmin liv salem oregon lowest price viagra 100mg colchicine availability in canada does diovan come in a generic form amantadine ms uk proventil hfa discount coupon acai berry sale stores buy sinequanone clothing losartan hydrochlorothiazide 100 mg- 25 mg inexpensive medrol dose pack maximum dose of viagra per day i pill myambutol website french cordial prepared from pomegranate juice non prescription online pharmacy reviews buy cabgolin in ireland pharmacy choice aspirin tretinoin cream australia can you get terramycin over the counter generic kytril for sale on line naprosyn side effects alcohol coreg cr from canada isotretinoin generic accutane buy ortho tri-cyclen online no prescription us can i get high off of meclizine cvs mail order prescriptions tamsulosin hcl 0.4mg side effects why is there a shortage of ephedraxin ordering elavil mexico lieu dung thuoc medrol what is azithromycin 250 mg prescribed for allegra drugstore available viagra with no hassles olanzapine withdrawal buying silagra from canada no prescription diclofenac gel pills antibiotic doxycycline infections seroxat and alcohol apo-azithromycin and alcohol consumption best online pharmacy generic prevacid where to buy lithium ion car battery medicament medrol prospect purchase levitra professional on line in the uk brand cialis reviews indian elavil deltasone on the internet doxazosin woldwide shipping what are the side effects of too much claritin can you order zaditor antihistamine eye drops voltaren 100 mg compresse acheter maison hammamet yasmine generic sinemet overnite shipping order abilify 15 mg where to seroquel cheap price drug buy online zyvox generic what is nitroglycerin cream used for 40 mg celexa reviews baytril noah discount code for vermox viagra and performance anxiety zithromax over the counter australia what is zyrtec used for asthma where to buy alli in the uk weight loss order pyridium online ventolin hfa pediatric dosage penegra express canada safe place to buy generic cialis fast shipping fluconazole suspension beat way to order acticin zofran store celexa order canada safe malegra fxt buy how to take levitra 10 mg is there a drug comparative to viagra sublingual buy benfotiamine online india buy lamisil oral online ordering diamox here in canada sinemet refills s club juniors now daisy reglan online pharmacy uk quanto costa il vermox minocycline 75 mg tablets compare prices alesse paroxetine online order buy carafate without a prescription from canadian pharmacy how to purchase decadron online what is the drug remeron for buy viagra online with prescription best place to buy alli in usa buy nitroglycerin from mexico online canadian generics no prescription best online zovirax labiale costo brand name tretinoin 0,025 online pfizer viagra no prescription research grade female cialis buy alligator meat wholesale louisiana plavix generic wikipedia drugs us online pharmacy no prescription nizagara where is keflex made where can i buy acai berry in canada fertomid in italia prometrium weight loss benefits depakote uk buy viagra pills for sale cheap cheap diclofenac diethylammonium gel generic snovitra super power online sales can i buy flagyl in canada feldene pill shop discount code cialis super active brand order i pill viagra sublingual website non prescription seroquel buy advair diskus online no prescription flonase price comparison order lanoxin canada what is zanaflex 4 mg for rumalaya liniment lawsuit desyrel generico italiano can you only get abilify on prescription kytril over counter uk i pill strattera website obat keputihan flagyl forte generic version of tetracycline low price januvia uk allopurinol generic wikipedia drugs generic pills for pletal augmentin and alcohol side effects eurax medication order hyaluronic acid pills side effects bystolic pharmacy coupons liquid mevacor review viagra levitra cialis generics cheap generic viagra jelly cheap synthroid uk buy nitroglycerin spray order paroxetine cheap buy lipothin online no prescription us illegal drug sales data buy astelin cheap generic 10ml similar to aciphex cyklokapron delivery uk can you buy prozac uk best place buy periactin pct is generic venlor available in usa no prescription betapace acticin order in the us reducing fluoxetine dose cheap skelaxin buy canadian pharmacy pyridium drug wiki atacand comprar lariam from usa pharmacy furosemide discount voucher where can i buy acai sorbet best overnight delivery of online viagra? buy arava with paypal quiero comprar aldactone can you buy saw palmetto over the counter in germany adalat best online non prescription pharmacy get caverta toronto prescription elimite olmesartan dose conversion ringworm medication for humans over the counter buy revia online naltrexone current price doxycycline low dose celexa drugs discount price 70 less vytorin discount coupon viagra professional where to purchase how to use lamisil cream for ringworm zoloft generic cost walmart compazine dose for kids fosamax price walgreens celexa compared to prozac costco pharmacy finax price amaryl dosage fertility drugs online buy differences in generic drug prices between the us and canada clomid success stories for women over 40 can you buy tadapox online zestril 20 mg much does cialis cost cvs purchase generic ventolin avapro complications doxycycline hcl 100 mg tablet use doxazosin coupon online do alligators live in mexico viagra soft 100mg cheep cialis and bph mechanism of action acai online order top 10 online vantin sites trusted online pharmacies review how much is depo provera without insurance vigrande 100mg kaufen purchase fluoxetine lowest price adalat online australia albendazole 20mg tab buy aldactone online canada discount lotrisone shipping overseas buy avandamet next day prilosec vs nexium side effects cipla eyes global pacts for cfc free inhalers which uk site to buy glucotrol xl differin gel on african american skin detrol phone orders united pharmacy finax cheapest zyvox in the uk levothroid compound purchasing dapoxetine online uk topamax medication order xenical diet pill does work dog anxiety medication benadryl what does bupropion xl 150 mg look like purchase zyrtec d phone in order for prilosec himcocid roche precio argentina buy clozaril without a prescription from canadian pharmacy for what medical problems is fosamax used buying plavix online zithromax dose for bronchitis lov cost flagyl er generic lexapro doesn;t work low cost isoptin online generic imitrex list 5 common side effects of coumadin therapy is generic ashwagandha effective pain meds no prescription online pharmacy uk bactroban cialis for daily use no prescription buyers of capoten canada omnicef online usa lilly cialis voucher antivert looking for what works better than lexapro pharmacy has best price isoniazid benemid no prescription canada tegretol online store pomegranate smoothie recipe vitamix white xanax bar street price why has penegra been discontinued aleve pain medication ingredients prograf on line buy xenical orlistat crestor us companies only secure morning after pill gonorrhea treatment guidelines 2010 zyloprim 40mg viagra tablets for men price aldactone side effects pregnancy diovan 80mg generic buy actos online with no prescription buy aleve inhaler canada mail-order phenergan buy exelon 10 buy cheap generic atarax no prescription metformin lawsuit pulmicort over the counter piracetam dosage guide where can i buy metformin for pcos purchase tricor lowest price low coreg high blood pressure drug information cleocin cream comprar ginette-35 original onde comprar zetia promethazine trade name india fertomid max dose colchicine generic removed from market where to buy suhagra online mexico exelon corp employment cheapest new liverpool kit 2013 where to get nitroglycerin where to buy amaryl promethazine in the uk now elimite lotion price order trental 120 mg moduretic drugstore v-gel online forum how many benadryl to take for an allergic reaction rx pharmacy software flagyl mg mexico buy colchicine mexican pharmacies wellbutrin sr mg price order avapro 300mg aciphex no prescription needed zithromax azithromycin tablets lasix 40 mg 12 tablet order himcocid tablets hyzaar overnight shipping cheap what is seroflo inhaler zoloft without rx zyrtec billig kaufen grocery store generic aisle teva bactrim shortage dilantin po loading dose sale order avalide mg bystolic australia price genuine decadron 100mg viagra soft tabs canadian comprar premarin crema no prescription needed for thyroid plus efficace viagra cialis levitra american pills viagra coumadin side effects uk generic prilosec otc omeprazole order motilium from canada without prescription generic hyzaar release date purchase generic parlodel buy cheap accutane using pay pal order ampicillin canada acai sales growth requip mail order india where is coumadin made buy cheap mircette using pay pal side effects of inderal 120 mg discount generic flomax generic name for cialis soft purim sublingual dosage lamictal ordering no prescription


dr Esad Bajtal

Pitali Kanamu, mudraca iz Tajfa:
- Otkad si čovjek?
Od prve misli, reče
- A, prije toga?
Bio sam samo rođen, odgovori

U svom članku “Odgovor na pitanje: što je to prosvjetiteljstvo“? (“Berlinische Monatsschrift”, 1784), I. Kant o biti toga pokreta kaže: Prosvjetiteljstvo je izlaz čovjeka  iz njegove samoskrivljene (selbsverschuldete) nezrelosti. Nezrelost je nemoć da se služimo svojim razumom bez tuđeg vođstva. Samoskrivljena je ova nezrelost, ako njezin uzrok ne leži u nedostatku razuma,već u nedostatku odlučnosti i hrabrosti, da se njime služimo bez vođstva nekog drugog.

Sapere aude! – Imaj hrabrosti, da se služiš vlastitim razumom!  To je, dakle, krilatica prosvjetiteljstva.

Naravno, Rene Dekart (R. Descartes), još prije Kanta, otklanja svaku eventualnu mogućnost nedostatka razuma kao razlog njegova nekorištenja, smatrajući da je isti ravnomjerno raspoređen među ljudima, i da su svi ljudi “po prirodi” sposobni da razlikuju istinu od zablude. U tom kontekstu, hrabrost služenja razumom pokazuje se kao temelj etičkog profiliranja individue; tj. hrabrost služenja sopstvenim razumom, postaje osnovom javnog životnog (građanskog) stava koji se (psiho)politički artikulira kao odvažno samopotvrđivanje individualnog sopstva u otporu spram opresivne, ili na neki drugi način civiliziranim uzusima življenja neprihvatljive vladavine vlasti. Tu hrabrost samopotvrđivanja sopstva kao razumnog bića odlučnog da samostalno misli sebe-u-svijetu ovdje nazivamo – građanska hrabrost. Stoga građansku hrabrost (odlučnost čovjeka na tragu svog društvenog i egzistencijalnog samopotvrđivanja), svodimo na “moć uma da savlada strah” koji socijalno-politički figurira kao efikasno i ideološki provjereno sredstvo kontinuirane kontrole i samokontrole (behavioralna autocenzura) javnog mnijenja.

Povijesno, takvo samopotvrđivanje čovjeka-građanina postaje razmjerno šire i ozbiljnije izvedivo tek descartovskim principom izvijesnosti oslonjene na epistemološki nepotkupljivu samosvijest individue s kojom, na životnu i društvenu scenu Zapada, stupa novi oblik “samolegitimacije ontološkog habitusa čovjeka”. U društveno-političkom smislu, radi se o uspostavljanju jednog epistemološki novog svijeta zasnovanog na aksiološki probuđenoj svijesti da ništa nije ni savršeno ni dovršeno, te da, u svojoj nedovršenosti (buddhističko-hegelovski: procesualnosti), mora, zarad javno zagovarane istinoljubivosti, stalno biti izlagano sudu raz/uma kao sudu raz-lučivanja istine i zablude, ma koliko inače, “to-nešto”, u svojoj datosti  izgledalo il/i zvučalo uvjerljivo i prihvatljivo. Jer, u svojoj psihodinamski zasnovanoj osuđenosti na kretanje (njem. Bewegung, eng. movement), “mišljenje je u biti negacija onoga što je pred nama” (Hegel). Kako povijesni ustroj stvarî, logikom heraklitovske mijene, podrazumijeva stalnost njihove negacije, ta se mijena societalno artikulira kao raz-umska konstituanta zova građanske pobune, tj., stava nemirenja sa postojećim, pa i onda kad je to postojeće sasvim dobro, prosto zato jer može (a građanin, kao – animal rationale – hoće), da bude – i bolje.

To razumno (logično) biće (animal rationale), Grci su zvali ζώου λόγον έχον, pri čemu ovo λόγον dolazi od λέγειν, što znači skupljati, suočiti se sa drugim, a prije svega nešto saopćiti u smislu iznijeti na vidjelo, i time iznesenom omogućiti da se pojavi iz svoje s(a)krivenosti. Korijen vid- sačuvan u našoj riječi “vidjeti”, sanskrtskog je porijekla (Vede) i pretežno znači – znati, što je do danas jasno sačuvano u slovenščini – védeti: Ja vem /ve(de)m/ = ja znam, tj. ja vidim kako stvari stoje. Odavde, samo onaj ko vidi (duhom, razumom), taj i zna.*

Dakle, “vidjeti”, u smislu – “znati“, znači: a) potvrditi prisustvo ili odsustvo stvari njihovim razumskim viđenjem; i, b) potvrditi sebe u tom viđenju, tj. mišljenjem posredovanom znanju (cogito, ergo sum).

Stoga, u okviru naslovljene teme, “nije individualno sopstvo kao takvo ono koje potvrđuje sebe, nego individualno sopstvo kao nosilac razuma. Hrabrost bivstvovanja kao sopstvo za sebe je hrabrost da se slijedi sopstveni razum i da se odupire iracionalnoj vlasti” (P.Tillich), kao neprihvatljivoj opreci spram izvorne racionalnosti svijeta; one racionalnosti iz koje nam raz-umsko razuma dolazi, i kojoj se, kritički opservirajući aktualnu datost svijeta, uvijek iznovo vraća.

Onoga časa kad, iz bilo kog razloga, prestane s borbom protiv te ne-racionalne opreke, hrabrost sopstva skončava u samopredajućoj se lagodnosti konformističkog pristajanja na dato. To je trenutak odustajanja od sveobuhvatnog sudjelovanja u univerzalnom, racionalnom samopotvrđivanju čovjeka; trenutak pada s višeg građanskog na niži podaničko-poslušnički nivo. U društveno-političkoj ravni riječ je o odustajanju od intelektualnog samjeravanja svijeta; odustajanju od njegovog po-umljivanja i njegovog po-razumljivanja kao načina uljuđivanja svijeta na principima kantovski zagovaranog ratia (ratia u njegovoj prosvjetiteljski zahtijevanoj hrabrosti i samokritičnosti).

Kroz prizmu kartezijanske metodske skepse kao osnove građanskog “refleksivnog senzibiliteta” vlast i država nužno gube tradicionalno-podaničke obrise himeričke nedodirljivosti. U svojoj naspramnosti ratiu sve dospijeva u ravan descartovske upitnosti i sumnje koja potvrdu sanjane izvijesnosti nalazi isključivo u sebi samoj: Samo je sumnja nesumnjiva. I samo samouvjerenost potire sumnju. Sve drugo podliježe dvojbom pobuđenom sudu razuma i svoj legitimni opstanak traži u njegovom odobrenju i odobravanju. I tu, s tom drčnom sumnjom u “nedodirljivo”, počinje mučna historija, historia calamitatum kao povijest krvavih nevolja, progona i političkih suđenja plejade najumnijh glava svijeta zbog njihovog samostalnog kritičkog mišljenja, onog mišljenja koje, ostajući vjerno postulatima logosa, ne pristaje na nesuvislost neobrazlo(g)ženih naloga Autoriteta (Crkve, Države, Ideologije, Vlasti, Vođe…).

Kao najpoznatije, i s aspekta najuzornije ispoljene građanske hrabrosti u povijesti, Sokratovo suđenje izgleda označava nepremostivu provaliju u kulturnoj historiji čovječanstva kojom individualna savjest i država, idealno i realno, bivaju grubo i nepomirljivo razdvojeni (M.Horkheimer). Sokratov gest nepristajanja postaje idealno-tipski paradigmatičan obrazac hrabrosti Velikog odbijanja.

U ime čega?

U ime etičkog zaziva odsutnog u prisutno, jer “que sommes – nous donc sans secours de će qui n’existe pas“.[1] Još preciznije: šta je zbilja spram istine o zbilji koja bi da se o-zbilji na način racionalne (resp. umne) mogućnosti svijeta. Čovjek kao animal rationale ne može a da ne računa s tim mogućnostima; ne može da se ogluši o racionalnu osnovu svijeta. Njegov ga Um, u svom kritičkom nemiru, neprestano pritiska ne samo da prepozna, već i da afirmira kako vlastite, tako i – racionalne mogućnosti svijeta. I da se, vođen tom spoznajom, izdigne iznad činjenica njegove datosti.

Ne pristajući na diktat činjenica, ljudski um ih, uvijek iznova, normativno-kritički podvrgava svojim mjerilima kao najvišim mjerilima povijesnog svijeta. Idući tragom Uma, gonjen kritičko-perfekcionističkim impetusom, animal rationale stiže do shvaćanja da je um nepomirljivi protivnik aktualnog stanja stvari; da je povijest kao borba uma protiv ne-uma, stalna borba za slobodu, i da “ne-umna zbilja treba da se mijenja, sve dok ne dođe u sklad sa umom”. U imperativu te mijene leži prirodni iskon ljudskog nezadovoljstva kao pokretačkog impulsa građanske hrabrosti koja, tražeći više i bolje, odbija mirenje s postojećim. Svako «jeste» svoju vrijednost mora provjeravati i potvrđivati u odnosu prema mogućem «treba da»; vrijednost se nikad ne izvodi iz činjenica, nego iz mogućnosti svijeta.

Da bi nešto bilo ljudski zbiljsko nije dovoljno (samo) da postoji, nego  da postoji “u obliku koji odgovara pravilima uma” (Hegel). A za to se treba izboriti u žestokoj borbi koja zagovara novi društveni plan koji je “u opreci sa datim poretkom”.  Toj borbi prethode savjest (kao etički izraz nemirenja), i hrabrost da se javno postupi po vlastitoj savjesti, kako se to pedagoški uzorno zbilo u Sokratovom slučaju. Bez (građanske) hrabrosti savjest bi bila samo žalostan gost[2] našeg života, a oglušivanje o nju konformistički ustupak vlasti koja (uglavnom) lagodno i neodgovorno živi upravo od savjesno-ućutkane i etički kastrirane, tj. kukavički pomirljive većine. Zato, pozivajući građane na dostojanstvo građanske hrabrosti, intelektualni velikan, nobelovac Albert Einstein, traži od njih da oslonac tog dostojanstva potraže u vlastitoj savjesti: “ne činite nikad ništa što se protivi vašoj savjesti, pa čak ako to od vas i država traži“.[3]


                        Šta je dobro, pitate?
                             Dobro je biti hrabar!
                                           F. Nietzsche 

Zašto hrabrost?

Zato što se, bježeći od uznemiravajućih promjena, svako ideološki etablirano društvo nastoji zaštititi koliko refleksnom, toliko i promišljenom instrumentalizacijom ljudskog straha. U tu svrhu ovladalo je brojnim tehnikama psihološkog presinga kao što su: prokazivanje i moralno diskreditiranje neistomišljenika, njihovo ucjenjivanje, zatvaranje, kažnjavnje, ekskomuniciranje, otpuštanje s posla…itd. Zapravo, “stvaranjem utiska da je neprekidno zauzeta suzbijanjem neprijatelja”, vlast se prividno opravdano i dodatno učvršćuje ne birajući pri tom ni sredstva ni načine tog učvršćivanja. U tom smislu svaka pobuna kao gest građanske hrabrosti predstavlja odlučan i dostojanstven odgovor savjesnog pojedinca na vlastodržačku manipulaciju strahom.

Još tačnije, kao etički uzoran odgovor na cinizam suzbijanja tobožnjih neprijatelja, građanska hrabrost je ne samo odvažna, nego i plemenita. Zato Platon odbacuje nagonsku, životinjsku hrabrost kao mogući model ljudske hrabrosti. Jer, ako je hrabrost prvenstveno vođena saznanjem šta treba odbijati, i u ime čega, onda ona ide samo uz čovjeka kao racionalno biće (animal rationale) spremno da “na sebe preuzme negativno koje nagovještava strah radi potpunosti pozitivnog” (P.Tillich).

Tek kao čin racionalnog samopotvrđivanja, hrabrost čovjeku daje dignitet bića koje se, uprkos brojnim rizicima, odaziva zovu svojih najdubljih ljudskih potencijala i tako sudbini odlučno kaže – Ne! Odgovor na pitanje porijekla te odlučnosti (koja nije opšta, tj. nisu svi ljudi hrabri), oslanja se na neke personalno-psihološke predpostavke pojedinca u njegovoj otvorenosti spram svojih egzistencijalno potiskivanih mogućnosti. Ta otvorenost podrazumijeva moć intuitivnog raspoznavanja onoga što je ljudskom biću unutarnje blisko. Na tragu te samobliskosti, «biti otvoren», znači čuti unutarnji zov ljudskog, i – odazvati mu se.

Čime je i na koji način određeno ponašanje ove vrste?

Odgovor je jednostavan – snagom savjesti čovjeka.