can vasotec cause weight gain buy beconase aq in australia propecia india sale betamethasone drops nose where is digoxin metabolized differin xp medication herbal viagra and poppers generic levitra super active safe cheap beconase aq uk buy prednisolone no prescription in uk can provera be purchased over the counter altace maximum dosage cymbalta reviews weight loss levaquin by mail attorneys drug xalatan pfizer buy accutane online uk no prescription mircette medicine online buy aleve boots comprar retin-a 0,05 portugal order alesse 21 online ditropan with no prescription can youtube buy cheap generic alphagan no prescription zyvox sale brahmi order canada propecia uk best price canadian family pharmacy phone number how many mg does it take to overdose on trazodone fosamax australia price furosemide shortage why zyvox online in us plendil where can i buy atarax side effects elderly valtrex dosage for genital herpes outbreak crestor 10 mg tablet cialis daily dosage effectiveness how to order promethazine with codeine online non generic levlen lawsuit effexor canada years rogaine 2 discount toradol 100mg buy safe buy viagra plus online kamagra uk contact number online pharmacy no prescription needed amaryl aleve dose for children prednisolone 5mg for dogs levitra professional canadian source allegra cost without insurance viagra professional without a perscription buy benemid online reviews suhagra fast india cost of generic valtrex buy innopran xl australia no prescription kamagra oral jelly lowest price pilex is it safe to order ginseng nizagara buy canada buy prinivil cheap buy relafen online from usa prescription mobic is for drug bayer 2006 form 20-f can i get pregnant while on fluoxetine where can you buy birth control pills in canada metformin hydrochloride tablets price micardis spain over counter motrin 400 mg tablets best online pharmacy generic lotrisone doxazosin echeck pfizer zithromax warning sinequan echeck buy zofran online india venlor discount voucher how long do the sexual side effects of paxil last fluoxetine hydrochloride side effects weight gain paxil class action lawsuit 2012 is it safe to order tenormin where will i buy diflucan online use of motilium 10mg tablets online pharmacy no prescription needed fluoxetine nitroglycerin without prescription cost of periactin without insurance pyrantel pamoate mebendazole or albendazole half price furosemide free coupon for cialis professional buy lexapro xr without prescription bupropion medication treatment hydrochlorothiazide company compazine dose oral purchase atomoxetine online generic calan compare prices levitra viagra cialis cheapest beconase aq to buy buy zithromax in the usa without prescription discount canadian pharmacy sominex comprar coumadin online buy eldepryl with e check pastillas omifin precio trial offer levitra can order famvir online comprar relafen original en madrid where to buy lozol with mastercard buy over the counter seroflo online purchasing rumalaya online uk herbal viagra tablets uk lov cost metformin lithium usa sale buy adalat overseas prilosec over counter drug como usar o serophene tetracycline shortage fda elocom kre'm 0 1 raloxifene hydrochloride buy z pack price cipralex withdrawal symptoms duration i pill zyrtec website tamoxifen vs arimidex weight gain colospa 100mg cheep when to take a pregnancy test after ovulation calculator cipro price walgreens order brand viagra cheap prednisone 20 mg for dogs ventolin inhaler max dose starlix order in the us lasix dose in ckd what is flagyl 500 mg tab for buy atarax hong kong pills 10mg drug market order paxil is kamagra soft available over the counter lamictal pharmacy coupons antabuse 200mg online where to buy revatio drugs online cost of singulair 10 mg tablet erection packs 2 for discount what is azulfidine used to treat existe algun tipo de viagra para la mujer flagyl substitute trimix computers reviews is mentat a prescription drug colospa spain buy singulair no prescription fast delivery norm lewis in cialis commercial citalopram hbr 20 mg get you high aleve purchase in canada no prescription low acticin viagra plus australia order stromectol uk pharmacy orlistat guidelines uk ciprobay 500 dosage for uti how long to take procardia celebrex cheap price skelaxin prices at costco tremor essencial propranolol dose rogaine 2 tablets uses ampicillin phone orders luvox side effects hair loss beconase aq drug store online prescription buy order abana natural viagra over counter australia maximum dose of trandate propranolol how to buy buyers of fincar canada mexican pharmacy no prescription nitrofurantoin buy yasmin online singapore purchase augmentin 875mg online how to take feldene mg mavi umut dershanesi o"g(retmenleri dosage of ranitidine for babies liposafe cheap uk ordering apcalis sx discount kamagra fast co uk elocon generic form what does the drug plavix do us online pharmacy no prescription brand viagra citalopram 20mg tablets alcohol order antabuse disulfiram online zithromax z-pak shelf life valtrex cost comparison order cialis canada pharmacy buy cyklokapron mexican pharmacies generic buspar used z pack antibiotic for sale where to buy cytotec online without rx cheap coupons buy zyprexa zerit shortage cheap terramycin buy online Purchase adalat 3 pharmacy keflex 10 mg cost adalat medication pregnancy order probalan online indian generics online alavert generic nolvadex uk can you buy avapro drug what is stronger vicodin or robaxin worldwide pharmacy periactin canadian ceftin online pharmacy approved lasix generic name furosemide worldwide pharmacy kamagra oral jelly dose of ceftin for sinus infection side effects of allicin garlic scary movie 4-viagra in italiano kamagra oral jelly generic 2013 drugs proscar reviews hair loss colchicine fast usa is percocet available in the uk pariet tablets research grade zyban how much aspirin can you take daily postcode search wordpress the online drugstore trimox prometrium 200 mg discount keppra doctors online price india ampicillin cheap buy valtrex online+au midamor tablets online aciclovir discount drugs zovirax ceftin western australia diamox medicine altitude sickness withdrawal from seroquel effects ultra low dose diflucan clomid serophene side effects coumadin for men sale in uk buy orlistat online from usa buy generic celadrin online myambutol prescribing information works best viagra levitra cialis order leukeran canada buy tenormin mg online erythromycin stearate 250 mg tablets where to buy viagra without prescriptions lopressor on line purchase voveran sr medication order cheap sinequan usa low price purim uk prozac and alcohol side effects best place buy generic viagra is generic requip effective phenergan 50mg tablets rhinocort aqua side effects children helena indian alliance inc what is crestor tablets for topamax tablets for sale best online pharmacy generic fucidin ceftin in italia cheap hotels near calangute where viagra australia pharmacy mexico buy part time pharmacy technician courses ireland low cost finpecia amoxil common side effects 1st rx pharmacy statesville nc pan american lithium corp news acyclovir side effects weight gain insurance age anxiety medication buspar oral finasteride dosage steroids generic procardia us zyprexa generic october 2011 how much will levitra super active cost buy coumadin online amazon metformin without prescription medication i want to pay some medrol viagra sublingual billig kaufen amoxil cheap us pharmacy bupron sr barato buy parlodel without rx amitriptyline dose for migraine prevention motilium shortage cuanto sale dramamine comprar fucidin en argentina order trazodone pill can you get high off paroxetine cheap dilantin pills pariet brands india gasex discount voucher purchase arjuna lowest price high blood pressure medication diltiazem best place to buy lisinopril in canada cheap levitra no prescription online drug protonix sold over counter topical spironolactone s5 cream generic flonase no prescription coreg annual sales blood pressure voltaren retard novartis pharma best price for luvox diabecon overnight delivery xenical 120 mg without prescription alli discount coupon savings where to buy acai berry pills in ireland 100 mg evista saw palmetto shampoo price in india generic alli buy kamagra jelly thailand viagra uk seller is it illegal to order drugs online from canada purchase revatio on line in india combivent medicines systemic side effects of xalatan purchase silagra on line in india insurance jobs board elocon to buy from europe what does generic protonix pill look like finasteride tablets ip 5 mg alcohol and blood pressure medication side effects singulair generico online medicine actos 30 mg canada order alli buy zaditor eye drops colospa on line purchase avalide pharmacy online generic inderal cost valtrex not generic aleve tablets uk cialis professional canada drug store what is requip medication used for how much will generic cymbalta cost belize-pharmacy-online what does cleocin t do cialis and other ed drugs order advairhfa without prescription neurontin generic cheap costs what does aciphex do where can i give toradol im pharmacy has best price motrin e45 hydrocortisone cream boots triamterene looking for buy lisinopril paypal accepted walmart $4 generic drug list 2012 retin a micro .1 canada canadian pharmacy vipps certified acheter alliance bruxelles used brahmin handbags sale cheap generic medrol 4mg where cani b uy xenical diet pill prednisone medicine for dogs professional no prescription canadian cheapest generic levitra lithium ion battery explosion amaryl 20mg tab eldepryl cost comparison prednisolone prescription drug diclofenac sodium side effects alcohol printable zyrtec coupons 2010 buy bactroban discount discount canadian pharmacy retin-a 0,05 ranitidine 150 mg tablet picture lipitor for sale in canada what is prevacid used for heartburn do you need a prescription for flagyl a*lesund lufthavn us online pharmacy no prescription levitra noroxin without a script yagara discontinued fastest blopress uk delivery is lisinopril better than diovan paxil prescription lawsuit reviews on brahmin bags procardia not generic what is actoplus met pills used for zofran mg canadian rx buy toprol xl mg femcare buy canada motilium suspension for babies 25 mcg levothyroxine weight loss buy meds from mexico online discount canadian pharmacy zocor tricare copay viagra can you only get viagra plus on prescription isoptin mg tablet buy retin-a micro gel online ranitidine 75mg tablets lithium 40mg uk pharmacies online that sell levitra famvir generic equivalent ethionamide without a script very cheap flovent kamagra generic viagra reviews buy clomid 50mg where frontal bone meets parietal bones buy levitra super active hong kong cheap zithromax uk can you buy zebeta discount bisoprolol sale lopressor online best place to order dostinex in us buy hydrea cheap erection pills for diabetics levitra plus phone orders accutane vs birth control pill for acne how much will diclofenac cost lloyds pharmacy online patient record evecare discount code zentel tablet side effects ordering zebeta here in canada cheap bactroban cream no prescription holistic medicine for lower back pain actonel prescription only buy actos 80 mg online ordering low dose diamox revia shoppers drug mart beconase aq online in usa furosemide generic trade micardis max dose buy generic tricor non prescription cytoxan pharmacy chloramphenicol 1000x recipe online pharmacy uk naprosyn pharmacy from india in usa how to order nimotop atorlip-10 lawsuit what drug category is kamagra gold prescription drug ephedraxin top drugstore makeup primers cleocin gel buy uk mobic anti-inflammatory tablets side effects side effects of prednisolone nhs genuine elavil best price insurance companies for young drivers discount alli coupons elocon side effects children atarax uk sale kamagra from uk trazodone on line purchase rimonabant user reviews lozol pas cher is sustiva a prescription drug medicine actos generic buy generic zyloprim online prednisone asthma treatment how long does it take citalopram to become effective buy ampicillin 40 propranolol hydrochloride price cefadroxil medication what are the side effects of flovent in children roxithromycin on the internet buy elimite mg how long do prednisolone tablets take to work buy viagra jelly quick pearl chemist london pamelor spain clomid capsules what are the side effects of prednisone therapy yagara not generic how to use panax ginseng extract midamor pas cher cialis sales 2009 nystatin and triamcinolone acetonide cream price alli libb american marketing association is generic ginette-35 available in usa zyrtec 5 mg tablet cheapest valtrex india buy fincar in india online how to take azithromycin 250mg dosage nexium 40mg side effects zyvox in croatia robaxin tablets canadian pharmacy 24 hour viagra approved zebeta online coupon code is watermelon really like viagra american antabuse apcalis sx for daily use canada beat way to order bystolic how to get cozaar on line aciphex side effects dizziness buy over the counter hyaluronic acid online buying aspirin in ireland the new order alliance drugstore can i use expired proventil inhaler generic reglan drug bactrim ds for acne how to use estrace cream buy generic clomid clomiphene brahmi gadi katha movie online do you need rx cialis sublingual prednisone cost comparison drugs lowest diovan sales us exclusivity zithromax to buy where can i buy cozaar mg buy cefadroxil inhaler canada american evista citalopram tablets what are they used for zyloprim express canada innopran cheap canada pharmacy brand prednisone buy reac,oes do remedio cloridrato de ciprofloxacino levitra online ordering lipothin precio mexico what;s the difference between cialis and viagra worldwide pharmacy cleocin gel half price viagra at tesco elavil us companies only isoniazid shop what is the medication synthroid used for trileptal 100mg cheep can buy zocor online drug market order lopressor best place to buy eurax rumalaya forte overseas serious side effects of depakote er exelon online pharmacy uk rumalaya overnight shipping cheap alavert india over the counter prevacid shortage tablets for increasing sex power cheap phenamax uk cialis sublingual cost where is the ginseng plant found legal buy prazosin online canada order generic avodart zoloft anxiety success stories buy generic ginette-35 online prednisolone sale uk benemid uk brand name can i get a birth control prescription without an exam ceftin online order where can i get siberian ginseng torsemide price india canadian health and care pharmacy acheter trazodone pas cher duetact overnight pharmacy cipro generic form dangers of stopping blood pressure medication propecia order online no prescription micronase ordering online pharmacy where can i get some elocon how much does korean ginseng cost buy triamterene patch where to buy himcocid drugs online amlodipine besylate 5 mg weight gain buy cialis super active next day exelon usa gabapentin 600 mg get high viagra professional sale sildenafil citrate minomycin india precio de la pastilla cialis en mexico uroxatral tablets side effects nizoral shampoo shortage 2012 astelin over counter drug cheap viagra fast shipping buying prednisone without precision where can i get maxalt cheap no prescription viagra super active sale lopressor dose conversion coumadin 1mg tablet game of thrones season 1 episode 2 where can i get diflucan online buy cheap levlen tablets 40mg metoclopramide for sale australia furosemide 12.5 mg price buy cephalexin in singapore florinef medication order kroger pharmacy hours lebanon tn how to buy minipress online pharmacy uk shallaki elavil 50 mg wikipedia wellbutrin usage can you gain weight too much synthroid stopping thyroid medication in cats aygestin for sale philippines how to buy pain pills in mexico viagra otc in mexico cheap emsam free delivery septilin overnight delivery meds similiar to singular imitrex injection cheap what does diflucan do to your body genuine coreg 100mg a good web page to buy indocin with no script cheap benzac 40 mg nymphomax comprare generic rhinocort for sale on line places that sell lotrel spironolactone acne nhs generic viagra sublingual in usa order avapro 150mg does medicare cover viagra prescriptions how much is keflex tablets revista tu online colombia buy cleocin paypal accepted order xenical without rx prednisone side effects in children hyper effects of drinking codeine cough syrup dramamine without rx cleocin gel australia pharmacy zithromax side effects heart what is kamagra gold pills used for cozaar pills color extendaquin online cheap generic septilin usa pharmacy lithium phone orders over the counter medicine that works like viagra buy alligators baby drug american danazol very cheap benicar

UN Affirms Right to Blaspheme

Late last month, the UN issued a new statement on the extent of freedom of speech under international law. It says that laws restricting blasphemy as such are incompatible with universal human rights standards.

The statement came from the Human Rights Committee, the body of eighteen “independent experts” mandated to monitor compliance with the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, or ICCPR, the 1966 human rights treaty that provides for freedom of opinion and expression and other fundamental rights. The Committee’s general comments represent authoritative interpretations of the provisions of the ICCPR. Unlike the highly-publicized resolutions produced by the Human Rights Council and the General Assembly, the provisions of the ICCPR are legally binding to its more than 165 parties.

The detailed 52-paragraph statement, General Comment No. 34, is the outcome of two years of intense debate among representatives of governments and civil society organizations. The Committee’s previous comment on freedom of opinion and expression, in 1983, was only four paragraphs long. In addition to taking up such matters as treason, defamation of heads of state, “memory laws” enforcing an official version of history, and the rights of bloggers, Comment 34 comes down strongly against religious limitations on speech. It does so not only by asserting that the right to free speech is foundational to a free and democratic society as well as to the protection and promotion of other rights. It also appeals explicitly to the values of freedom of conscience and equality before the law.

According to paragraph 48, “Prohibitions of displays of lack of respect for a religion or other belief system, including blasphemy laws, are incompatible with the Covenant, except in the specific circumstances envisaged in article 20, paragraph 2, of the Covenant.” Article 20, paragraph 2 calls on states to prohibit “advocacy of national, racial, or religious hatred that constitutes incitement to discrimination, hostility, or violence.” The Comment is careful to require that any restrictions must not violate the Conventions’ guarantees of equality before the law (Article 26) and freedom of thought, conscience, and religion (Article 18).

Thus, for instance, it would be impermissible for any such laws to discriminate in favor of or against one or certain religions or belief systems, or their adherents over another, or religious believers over non-believers. Nor would it be permissible for such prohibitions to be used to prevent or punish criticism of religious leaders or commentary on religious doctrine and tenets of faith.

Laws against blasphemy or “religious insult” (found throughout the world, including half of all Council of Europe member states) are inherently discriminatory against secularists and religious dissenters. They are discriminatory in that secularists have no legal recourse—nor should they—when the words of believers offend their moral sensibilities, nor can gays take the publishers of Leviticus to court for the spiritual affront to them that it surely is. Skeptics and heterodox believers, on the other hand, do have an Article 18 right to live and speak according to their conscience even when it offends the orthodox.

Paragraph 32 of the new comment also cautions states against employing a narrow notion of so-called public morals to restrict speech, effectively ruling out laws that defer to a particular faith tradition: “the concept of morals derives from many social, philosophical and religious traditions; consequently, limitations... for the purpose of protecting morals must be based on principles not deriving exclusively from a single tradition.”

The implication of these recommendations is that controversies over blasphemy are not just conflicts between “free speech” and faith, but clashes between competing claims of conscience.

The message of General Comment No. 34 is not only a clear condemnation of the blasphemy laws of countries such as Pakistan, which despite having ratified the ICCPR in 2008, continues to impose the death sentence for blasphemy and “defiling” the name of Prophet Muhammad. The Comment equally repudiates the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, which has upheld Austrian, British, and Turkish laws against blasphemy and religious insult by invoking a sui generis right to “respect for the religious feelings of believers.”

Civil society activists now have the final legal authority of the United Nations on their side as they press governments to come into compliance with their treaty obligations and bring an end to the criminalization of blasphemy.