what is buspar side effects where to buy tretinoin cream 0.025 finast max dose best price viagra sublingual purchase aldactone in us over counter medrol pilex pills generic advair diskus 10 50 what type of depression is wellbutrin prescribed for medco mail order prescriptions order form prescription free generic paxil masters in clinical pharmacy in canada buy zyprexa 10 generic viagra reviews forum relief pharmacy low-dose finasteride hair loss dose dependent bradycardia with citalopram in an elderly patient lasting effects of accutane depression haldol in australia atomoxetine side effects buy cardizem usa cheap atorlip-20 no prescription best place buy xenical side effects of prednisone with alcohol cleocin gel spain over counter shatavari churna in usa glyset medication side effects where can i buy yagara in canada lithium online in canada post cycle therapy nolvadex xt diclofenac sr 100mg baclofen birth control online us pcos clomid 100mg success stories acyclovir over the counter status order phenergan pills vermox no script how to get doxazosin on line premarin coupons pills where purchase benadryl zebeta tablets on line to buy indian pharmacy amaryl avalide medication pregnancy best price abana otc comparable to hydrochloriazide www canadian pharmancy 24h.com where to get seroflo prilosec no prescription compare prices generic vermox us best lopressor prices buy canada no prescription for pyridium carafate for sale philippines mentax generic name best paroxetine prices aripiprazole generic india watch tulasi movie online free cheap atorlip-5 uk which uk site to buy zebeta albuterol without rx betamethasone valerate ointment side effects to buy propecia 5mg uk is generic zestril effective augmentin xr 1000 mg dosage what is advair hfa used for fertomid barato order wellbutrin sr tablets online pet medication store cymbalta and anxiety does it work alphagan p 0.15 eye drops order what do alligator lizards eat what drug category is apcalis sx what is viagra jelly who has claritin on sale over the counter inhaler rite aid buy rumalaya liniment bulk alli diet pills uk boots side effects of lexapro 10 mg evista buy canada buy shuddha guggulu lowest price drugs similar to buspar compare prices aciphex flonase in canada fertomid ordering online pharmacy beconase aqueous nasal spray to buy what is furosemide 20 mg tab for buy metformin online australia preciso de receita para comprar dostinex viagra now uk current gold price live update generic from risperdal cuvarlix orlistat 120mg best non prescription erectile dysfunction what does amitriptyline hydrochloride make you feel like zestril trusted online drug stores in canada ginseng tea overnight phgh rx buy buy casodex online purpose of flomax medication roche orlistat uk shortage lexapro on line in the mexico are alligators mammals bystolic weight gain message boards prazosin tablets from buy is generic tenormin available in usa generic lasix india post cycle therapy paxil antivert non prescription caverta 10 mg cost zenegra to buy from europe etodolac generic wikipedia drugs metoclopramide hydrochloride 10 mg im injection suprax cefixime 400 mg side effects phamcheapmeds.com tofranil supplier in uk nifedipine tablets what is depakote er 500mg without food take reglan buy zyrtec with visa what is finasteride 5 mg used for can you get acivir pills tadacip noprescrition needed usa online pharmacy necesito receta medica para comprar metformina discount coupon for crestor discount canadian pharmacy moduretic brand advair diskus cost canadian cheap allopurinol prescription competitive liv 52 mg tablet pharmacy that sells baclofen canadian no written prescription needed what is medrol used for in ivf can you really buy viagra on the internet avandamet prices cvs can drink alcohol after accutane lipitor lawsuit side effects viagra jelly supplier in uk paroxetine overdose emedicine where can i purchase adalat promethazine codeine syrup online canada combivent tablets lexapro discount card retail price mircette where can i buy dilantin list of anti anxiety drugs seroflo 250 inhaler used for what xanax erowid vault cheap alli 83 safe to buy generic femara from uk yagara online in usa cheap capoten uk prescription tamoxifen from india zaditor delivery london diltiazem refill pack buy hydrochlorothiazide 40 lexapro ordering online pharmacy promethazine rx elimite 100mg cheep motilium dosage for lactation valtrex no prescription generic asthma treatment ladder pharmacy that sells differin where to purchase fucidin buy aleve patch motilium 10mg domperidone janssen-cilag prevacid online india fucidin over counter canada cheap genuine neurontin online ibuprofen alcohol mayo clinic what is mometasone furoate will short term use of prednisone cause weight gain trileptal 600 mg price como se usa el zovirax prednisone tablets on line to buy triamterene hydrochlorothiazide brand name lamictal medication bipolar free alli coupons printable where can i buy non-drowsy dramamine allopurinol drugstore acidity body antibiotic ceftin side effects can online pharmacies be trusted going off celexa weight loss florida alligator park miami purina one indoor advantage hairball healthy weight management formula cats buy dramamine online no prescription united states how to take glucotrol xl side effects of doxazosin cardura compare prices shallaki order dostinex pill ginseng now foods when will lexapro be available in generic form buy noroxin mg online can i buy zebeta in canada plavix generic date 2012 is alphagan available on line in canada sex power tablet name buy fluoxetine without a prescription trileptal online pay paypal cheap genuine diamox online most common side effects of cipro dc united supporters club trazodone next-day drowsiness indian alcohol policy alliance generic actos availability buy hytrin usa terbutaline sulfate drug study snovitra super power drug schedule no prescription smoking alesse online discount canadian pharmacy tadapox buy naprosyn without a script non prescription extendaquin buy kamagra overseas is there a drug comparative to lanoxin buy cheap alli tablets order arimidex online where to buy rogaine 2 no prescription cytotec sale online pharmacy no prescription needed canada erythromycin base 500mg dosage when should i increase my zoloft dose purchasing lamisil online canadian family history online without a transcript cod aceon where can i buy genuine viagra online purchase orlistat 60mg trazodone 50 mg tablet side effects speman precio mexico oral prescription medicine for cold sores what is the empiric dose for acute digoxin toxicity overseas pharmacy no prescription colchicine cialis daily vs 36 hour shallaki legal in england rosuvastatin weight gain buylowdrugs coupon combivent nebs the best online pharmacy reviews cheap vermox buy online purchase albendazole pills buy lamictal 200mg is mail order micardis safe where to colchicine price canadian acai berry buying guide levitra tablets us online propranolol stores flomax over counter alternative where can you get doxycycline maximum safe dosage of levitra where is allianz park generic neurontin switzerland cardura purchase in canada no prescription proscar dose for hair loss buy xenical pills singapore what is mestinon tablets lioresal tablets side effects how much will remeron cost Purchase tenormin 50 mg betnovate cream usage cabgolin buy uk levothroid dosage hypothyroidism brand cialis order online cheap deltasone us rx canadian pharmacy vipps approved acquistare aleve in italia online pharmacy delivery ireland orlistat without a script does pharmacies in mexico sell clomid buy skelaxin with shallaki pharmacy order yagara generic reviews how to order septra buy atorlip-5 online pharmacy canadian alliance of physiotherapy provincial cheap generic anafranil compare prices cialis sublingual buy cheap advair diskus online phone in order for finax doxycycline dosage for lymes disease can you get strattera over counter amantadine ms reviews purchase levitra super active pills buy antivert us what is buspar 10mg recommended dosage of avodart voltaren prices walgreens zovirax online coupons buy haridra mg online good reviews on fosamax buy cipro from canada order colchicine online no prescription with a amex amantadine ms uk ponstel legal in england my alli coupons 2011 nolvadex pills online in the usa has propecia become generic phenergan uk otc abilify for schizophrenia reviews cytotec generic brand where can i buy retin-a 0,025 minocin without rx orlistat comprar brasil order cefixime cheap isotretinoin generic accutane acai 40 mg dose cvs mail order prescriptions can you drink alcohol while on viagra erexin co uk herbal diclofenac gel pills seroxat and alcohol benfotiamine shopping cheapest leukeran indian generics online mycelex-g calan barato can you buy ponstel over the counter premier league stats buy actoplus met online cheap how to buy ciprofloxacin minipress max dose tegretol generic cheap costs sibutramine hydrochloride best place to buy nizoral in india can you order zaditor antihistamine eye drops unicure noida buy nizoral 2% shampoo paxil 20 mg 28 tablet renagel delivery london legal buy inderal online canada clomid post cycle side effects order cardura overnight finpecia from can you buy antibiotics uk online without buy artane with no rx where to purchase caverta buy chloromycetin online reviews doryx acne medicine side effects buspar pills sale order apcalis sx prescription suhagra costco natural anti anxiety medication canada water pills holland and barrett where is game of thrones filmed in iceland shallaki pharmacy prices list mail order cialis soft cephalexin dosage for adults ranitidine dose for babies buy elimite singapore increasing sperm count and motility compare prices geriforte syrup prescription cheap buy estrace avalide overseas cheap exelon 100 mg list non prescription drugs ireland comprar penegra original en madrid metronidazole and tinidazole pregnancy is beconase better than flonase high blood pressure medication lopressor comprar cialis online em portugal purchasing singulair online cost of kamagra chewable without insurance where to buy aciphex what is estrace 0.01 cream used for medrol dosepak 4 mg oral ventolin online europe retin mg no prescription recommended dosage azithromycin chlamydia max safe dose of aspirin order bupropion floxin discount voucher celebrex billig kaufen glucophage 500 precio mexico serophene online in usa penegra 100 dosage cheap yasmin india accutane drug in fr pharmacy snovitra super power online sales what are the side effects of ventolin hfa reviews on nizoral shampoo pravix by ,mail eurax how to buy allopurinol generic wikipedia drugs buy strattera 20 canadian pharmacy 24-h com robaxin on line in the india prometrium canadian pharmacy liquid mevacor review what does nitroglycerin do to your heart oregon state football how much do benadryl cost where to buy acai berry detox in stores artane prices at costco blue oval pill with watson 387 on it no prescription betapace ordering maxalt neurontin medication where to buy alphagan online overnight shipping cheapest claritin tablets uk comparison of viagra , cialis and levitra buy biaxin 50 current price doxycycline names of drugs for depression and anxiety tadalafil 10mg supplier zetia doctors online where can i get beconase aq what is apo-paroxetine used for order antabuse from australia without prescription discover scotland metoclopramide cheap uk buy differin boots prednisone diabetes lawsuit where is lamictal manufacturer order penicillin vk online cost of zetia 10 mg fenofibrate dose administration lioresal maximum dosage buying sumycin for dogs prandin medication where to buy buy motilium suppositories online vasotec with american express micardis purchase in canada no prescription albuterol over the counter canada flomax generic 2013 drugs maxalt pas cher italie funny generic viagra names canadian pharmacy online legit suppliers of baclofen in us dvd australia buy online do alligators live in mexico amoxil overseas acai online order trusted online pharmacies review youtube robin williams viagra french pharmacy beauty products online cheapest drug betnovate retin-a 0,025 not generic adalat online australia anastrozole 1mg tablets bodybuilding what class of drug is lexapro for pregnancy alfa access renova group where can i buy minocycline in canada where can i buy prozac for my dog viagra family pack canadian himcolin prescription coupon anafranil online shipping order atarax online cheapest zyvox in the uk buspar reviews 2010 fda pharmacy appe rotation is generic flovent available in usa dog anxiety medication benadryl buy bactroban generic lowest price sustiva side effects of strattera 40 mg zithromax australia price comprar cytotec costa rica no prescription atacand sale buy evista in india online fast lotrisone delivery what is glyburide metformin amoxil overnight 500mg prescription zithromax dose for bronchitis cost propecia india carafate visa proscar wiki zyrtec generic side effects fucidin delivery cheap allegra canadian pharmacy where to buy nimotop ointment omnicef online usa doxycycline from cvs best price viagra 100 mg order propranolol pill getting albuterol online trazodone pill shop discount code calcium carbonate compare prices ordering clozaril india buy kamagra online in usa styplon medication side effects vitamin k dosage for coumadin toxicity seroquel to buy in australia buy kytril mg comprar methotrexate original pharmacy alli usa benadryl rx dosage bactrim online ordering what does promethazine codeine syrup treat aldactone dosage children generic flomax reviews liv 20mg tab evista uk buy mexican online pharmacies steroids prior legit online pharmacies forum buy aleve inhaler canada canadian allies and enemies what is rimadyl all types purim pills ativan overnight no prescription purchase motilium in mexico how do you order pills online how to order diovan what is diovan hct levitra online pharmacy no prescription viagra generic lipitor release date in us advair diskus visa what is atorlip-5 fertomid max dose sandoz-rabeprazole 10 mg overnight delivery order aldactone president janssen-cilag france best place buy lotrisone pct buy fincar 5 abana reviews for men alesse no prescription canada get serevent toronto prograf tablets uses cordarone no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy crestor billig kaufen bactrim max dose cheap drugs to make herbal medicine suppliers uk cleocin t 1 lotion low aciphex esophagitis zithromax azithromycin tablets order himcocid tablets bioshock nitroglycerin walkthrough legal to buy betnovate lowest price neurontin levitra super active tablets from buy oder mg tablets of ethionamide viagra super active 100 review prescription innopran xl imiquimod warts children purchase singulair lowest price generic actoplus metformin genuine decadron 100mg viagra soft tabs canadian flagyl tablets 400mg coumadin questions Purchase abilify 15mg online plus efficace viagra cialis levitra compare prices albendazole lincocin prices usa viagra def50 finasteride brand names propecia proscar how to use hoodia for weight loss phone in order for biaxin generic form of celexa feldene over counter vytorin pill canadian mirapex used for fibromyalgia natural testosterone cream made compounding pharmacy buy benicar australia prevacid dose pediatric acai sales growth requip mail order india buying prednisone prescription in store what is the correct dosage of celebrex

Chaplaincy program back in the dock of the High Court

Ron Williams is the father of four children at Darling Heights State School in Toowoomba, Queensland. Like many other schools, it has a chaplain funded by the federal government. Williams took objection to this, saying taxpayers should not pay for a religious position in a state school.

Williams has taken the remarkable step of fighting for his beliefs all the way to the High Court. On Monday, his legal team will argue before the court that the chaplaincy scheme is unconstitutional.

The case is the most anticipated of the year. If Williams succeeds, the court may not only strike down the chaplaincy scheme, but also hundreds of other federal programs worth billions of dollars. The result could rewrite the book on how the Commonwealth and the states spend public money.

The battle against the chaplaincy program has spanned several years. Williams first challenged the scheme in the High Court in 2010. He argued then that the program breached the separation of church and state and, in particular, section 116 of the constitution which says "no religious test shall be required as a qualification for any office or public trust under the Commonwealth". This argument failed.


A second argument won him the day. He said the federal government lacked the power to spend money on the chaplaincy scheme because the scheme lay outside of its power. Williams successfully challenged the long-standing assumption that the federal government can spend taxpayers’ money without the specific support of Parliament on whatever program it wishes.

In ruling this way, the High Court delivered a surprising new limit on federal power. It emphasised what many had forgotten – that the nation was not created with a dominant Commonwealth in mind, but as "a truly federal government". The court also reasserted the principle that governments can spend money only with parliamentary approval.

These ideas were used to overturn the chaplaincy program, and had much wider implications. In the decision’s aftermath, then attorney-general Nicola Roxon identified 427 programs as lacking any visible constitutional support. They amounted to as much as $37 billion a year, or 10 per cent of all federal expenditure.

The federal funding programs under threat ranged from pork-barrelling to good public policy. They included drought assistance and disaster relief, support to the car industry, numerous local initiatives, indigenous education and employment, laptops in schools, refugee support schemes, community policing, climate change research and support for children with disabilities.

There was no doubt the Commonwealth could continue to fund these activities if it did so via the states. This is permitted by section 96 of the constitution. However,involving the states in these programs would have meant sharing some of the responsibility and political benefits. As a result, the federal government decided to shore up its position in a different way.

Within a week of Williams’ High Court victory, a law was rushed through both houses of Federal Parliament. It gave the stamp of approval to all these funding schemes in one big block. One such scheme rescued from oblivion was the chaplaincy program.

This paved the way for Williams’ second foray into the High Court. He is now once again challenging the chaplaincy program, and in doing so the federal government's entire rescue package. The significance of the case is reflected in the fact that every state will attend the court to put their position.

Williams will again argue that the federal government lacks the power to fund chaplaincy services in state schools. He will also say the special law passed by Parliament to give legislative backing to this and other schemes is either ineffective or unconstitutional.

The federal government by contrast is arguing that its rescue package is valid. It is also taking the rare step of asking the High Court to declare that its earlier decision in favour of Williams was wrongly decided.

There is a good chance the challenger will again emerge victorious. Strong doubts were expressed about the validity of the rescue law at the time it was passed. The doubters included Senator George Brandis, who said from opposition that he was "far from satisfied" that the fix "is effective to satisfy the constitutional lacuna which the High Court identified".

Brandis now finds himself in the position of Attorney-General, and so must defend the scheme in court. He can only hope that his prediction proves ill-founded, or he will face a big headache. A second loss in the High Court may mean that there is no easy fix for a range of federal funding programs, many of which are important to local communities and politically popular.

Such a result may require a rethink of how the federal government spends public money. One option is for it to cease several of its funding programs. An alternative would be to direct money to the states to spend on its behalf. Neither choice would be palatable for it.

George Williams is the Anthony Mason professor of law at the University of NSW.

Source: The Age