propecia online us pharmacy original cardizem online research grade snovitra super power can you buy viagra soft in ireland canadian pharmacy tegretol delivery what does cipro treat sertraline overdose side effects metformin hydrochloride tablets ip 500 mg side effects allegra no prescription compare prices order amantadine canada ventolin drug in uk pharmacy cialis commercial song basement no rx viagra super active online cialis sale canada viagra levitra dose comparison how to order phenamax online sarafem 10 mg for pms where can i get some lotrisone zetia generic date blopress generic 2013 drugs lamotrigine paypal overnight shipping seroquel drug oversea bystolic medication used mexican pharmacy no prescription viagra plus order advair diskus 250mcg 50mcg pharmacy overseas pharmacy no prescription revia can i buy ventolin over the counter in ireland high dose methotrexate toxicity seroquel buy india depression medication paroxetine buy luvox online at canada pharmacy do you need rx vytorin canada xenical tablets online ventolin interactions other drugs generic propecia finasteride 5mg sarafem western australia better than betnovate best price for propranolol legal buy elavil online canada generic uk paypal retin-a 0,025 where to buy hytrin ointment valacyclovir 2.5 mg where to buy xalatan in canada safely non persciption lady era cheap augmentin us view topic buspar shop net can buy lamisil over counter order nj rx pads where to buy viagra in birmingham tenormin coupons actoplus met cost canadian florida allopurinol tetracycline birth control online india viagra originale costo brand cialis online sales what does amaryllis symbolize sinemet how to buy tinidazole usa sale can you buy levitra in ireland can you take cardura daily antabuse without a script canada drugs carafate with prescription best price for amaryl buy duetact hong kong buy cheap cytotec using pay pal canada order prilosec over the counter medicine that acts as viagra professional depakote drug wiki rihanna s and m generic vasodilan cost what is hoodia gordonii extract zantac from usa pharmacy canada order tretinoin 0,05 cheapest place to buy keflex buy chloramphenicol online safely us online pharmacy no prescription zantac side effects of benadryl cream cheapest kamagra online doxycycline 100mg tablets online guardian pharmacy singapore contact details where can i order finax nizagara tablets side effects haldol 20 mg prandin australia price where to buy levothyroxine insulin tablets generic from lioresal amitriptyline dosage for sleep indian risperdal unique hoodia cost fosamax overnight pharmacy lincocin for purchase without a prescription generic estrace side effects half inderal la 80 mg side effects buy parlodel online overnight mexican pharmacy no prescription motilium seroquel reviews patients remeron uses medication lotrisone australia buy zithromax now order accutane online no prescription cheap how to use clomid correctly zofran lawsuits where can i buy propecia in singapore cefadroxil online usa no prescription prilosec mexico generic buy clavamox cats no prescription order femara no rx canadian pharmacy hydrea to buy from europe best place to buy zantac in usa alesse 28 missed pills best price on brand name cialis bactrim online from usa fincar reviews for men viagra levitra same time ponstel daily use reviews ropinirole hydrochloride abuse erection packs 3 purchase proventil tablets from buy is propecia for women safe can diflucan make you gain weight buy cheap tamoxifen no prescription norco aurum 2012 order brand amoxil from usa without prescription viagra super active shortage lady era online meds cipla finpecia review ayurslim uk buy cialis difference viagra vs levitra which is better buy eulexin fast shipping estrace usa buy canada no prescription for singulair is lexapro available in canada quibron-t cost in canada abilify without a prescription from uk best generic triamterene sites aldactone 10 mg tinidazole sublingual dosage buy cheap celebrex no prescription zyvox online canada cod trandate tablets for purchase is generic propecia from india safe cordarone without a prescription irbesartan hctz dose bad side effects of acai berry pills ordering low dose minocin do you need a prescription for phenergan in australia phexin without a prescription generic kamagra soft buy canada how to use synthroid for weight loss boots drugstore in canada is zetia generic dapoxetine online usa best cialis soft prices cheapest 20mg adalat composition vpxl for sale philippines prednisolone drug oversea levlen usa sale how long does it take for bentyl to leave your system cost of prinivil computer rx pharmacy software oklahoma city singulair cost etodolac pill shortage canada and atorlip-5 medicare drug coverage viagra list of tesco stores selling sominex viagra super active on line in the mexico buy canada no prescription for calan nitrofurantoin no prescription reviews buy valtrex tablets generic metformin online in us buy propranolol online indian allies of the french were hong kong pharmacy online 1 jar 1 man original video medrol online from uk where to buy brahminy blind snake how to order shallaki is viagra safe yahoo answers artane spain buy cheap diclofenac gel best drugstore foundation 2013 uk diltiazem 40mg doxycycline hyclate 100mg cap used for us online pharmacy no prescription relafen best price for actoplus met clomid and serophene cost strattera usa arati sharma national director the canadian alliance of student associations lov cost alphagan betoptic tablets long time side effects celexa bula do remedio cloridrato de ciprofloxacino low cost emsam robaxin side effects long term valtrex for purchase avapro hct side effects roxithromycin no prrescription finax tablets uk overnight erection packs 2 without buy online actos 10 mg cost avalide where can i buy viagra fu"r die frau kaufen sale provera femcare sold over counter cheap cialis jelly free delivery what is propecia used for health canada cardizem dapoxetine sublingual dosage generic lincocin in usa olanzapine generic name famvir medicine online metoclopramide 10 mg prospect suprax wanted online review clomid pregnancy stories furosemide drugs interact buying tegretol from canada no prescription can i make elavil order viagra online australia discount donde comprar propecia colombia endep side effects 10mg what is strattera made of what does doxazosin mesylate do zithromax canadian pharmacy cheap living options in london order diovan 120 mg cheap genuine floxin online snovitra super power uk buy where can i buy eurax cream can order amoxil online inhouse pharmacy discount coupon hcg weight loss injections online orlistat availability october 2012 carafate discount medications zanaflex tizanidine allopurinol discounts allegra online store cheap advair mg is there any medication for anxiety over the counter mentat maximum dosage lortab 7.5 325 oregon state treasury investment division etodolac tablets from buy medicine cardura 4 mg cipro flagyl headache difference between cozaar losartan potassium ceftin with no rx travelling overseas with ventolin online sale of voveran lipitor with or without food sinemet no prescription canada buy generic cialis usa generic naprosyn 500mg adderall abuse side effects adults betnovate c benefits venta alli online lamictal cost generic antibiotics order no prescription when will singulair be available in generic form bystolic uses medication resources for sumycin discount januvia from canada buy brand antabuse pain meds that start with the letter k cheap meds without rx how to buy fosamax kiss 100 live stream kenya indinavir canada overnight delivery do people abuse prednisone cymbalta supplier in uk buy levaquin online us premarin prescription coupon vermox shopping order phexin canada get cialis online canada ephedraxin pills drugstore avodart 0.5mg side effects purchase sinequan pharmacy cod capoten discount medrol tablets what is it used for apteka lexapro comprar clomid on line where do i doxycycline in uk what are the side effects of doxycycline hyc lisinopril delivery london mobic online cheap triamterene on line for sale no script buy claritin inhaler canada ordering keflex online where to buy colchicine tablets usp order generic pilex to buy zyprexa ordering low dose diovan mexico buy reglan can you pay by check at walmart buy cheap trandate pills taking clomid right after miscarriage torsemide uses medication ipratropium bromide albuterol sulfate dosage kamagra oral jelly how to take tofranil online legally visa electron provera stanja can you buy benadryl in japan acquistare florinef in italia where can i buy pilex tablets stilnox online uk chelsea drugstore kings road generic altace hct walmart pharmacy price celebrex top 10 cefixime brands in india top 200 drugs 2010 pharmacy times order voltaren emulgel keppra comprar brasil cipro 1000 mg a day vpxl generic wikipedia drugs were can i buy acutne best price for hydrochlorothiazide lantus cheap canada pharmacy best generic glucotrol xl review can youtube buy cialis jelly in ireland buy glucophage no prescription mastercard buy generic vpxl online with prescription altace roche precio argentina minipress generic for voveran sr capsules etodolac order canada can you take dutas daily dilaudid hydromorphone rectal generic glycomet no prescription can buy water pills over counter florinef discounts codes how to use lasix for bodybuilding best fertility drugs for men order amitriptyline overnight will you buy viagra soft in ireland canadian is viagra for premature ejaculation my alli coupon printable ordering cialis soft mexico how much clomid to take post cycle uk version of paroxetine the online drugstore purim average price viagra uk long term side effects of lithium carbonate novartis voltaren sr 100 lamisil tablets australia generic serophene paypal purchase kamagra soft pills seroquel xr canadian pharmacy crestor coupons astrazeneca mexico allegra prescription where can i buy paroxetine fish cycline forte for acne order hydrochlorothiazide pill hyaluronic acid next day birth control pills viagra plus kamagra tablets free shipping how long does it take for requip to work aspirin drug class roxithromycin in canada stieva-a cream singapore elavil online without prescription olanzapine cheap canadian zyvox tablet indian generics online estrace keppra price compare the online drugstore minocycline trazodone medication side effects lithium by mail order generic cymbalta 60 mg walmart rumalaya forte no prrescription buy finast mg online femara infertility twins can you buy cardura what does prevacid do diclofenac gel brands india serpina online uk levlen side effects long term use luvox drug schedule plavix product information australia dutasteride buy canada no prescriptio mexican pharmacy no prescription renagel what drug category is rumalaya liniment all types keppra pills retin-a 0,025 tablets can take cialis levitra together evista cheap uk no prescription inderal what is doxycycline hyclate 100mg tab used for what is the usual dosage of methotrexate for ra can you buy allegra in ireland is it safe to buy prescription drugs from mexico lipitor dosage cytoxan lawsuit forum buy phenergan online order methotrexate generico italiano cialis soft buy on line wholesale cialis viagra professional canada head office rumalaya liniment roche precio argentina how to buy metoclopramide in london discontinued use of wellbutrin how fast does wellbutrin start working alphagan weight gain buying nexium using paypal overnight lexapro canadian pharmacy otc drugs mexican propranolol mg courier viagra professional from uk nizoral 2 shampoo doxycycline mg mexico effexor xr 150 mg weight gain buy tinidazole paypal accepted starting and stopping blood pressure medication over counter triamterene buy luvox online from canada cialis commercial 2011 youtube retin a 0.1 minocycline now buy procardia inhaler canada misoprostol cytotec in italia manufacturer of topamax tablets buy baclofen 10mg online cialis soft supplier in uk yasmin paypal cialis daily 5 mg can i make urispas online pharmacy uk aricept evista without a prescription altace for men in usa my l-tryptophan coupons aleve coupons canada printable tenormin echeck low cost arava erexin price trazodone 150 mg tablet picture parlodel weight gain how to buy didronel minocycline rx cost of arimidex at walmart zetia patient reviews what is the best foundation for dry skin no prescription avapro sale viagr with mastercard online buy clonidine without kamagra gold how to buy hydrochlorothiazide no prescription compare prices generic for avodart 0.5 mg buy zyrtec eye drops buy aldactone new zealand online cheapest nolvadex uk valtrex for type 1 herpes can you get danazol over the counter viagra dosage recommended 12.5 is rumalaya gel available over the counter order zyvox online sinequan without a script cialis soft medication where to buy american vantin best site to buy imitrex what does acai fruit taste like benadryl 100 ct is cialis better than viagra why is there a shortage of caverta is mail order viagra super active safe levitra tablets in south africa can buy prednisolone online combivent over the couter european pharmacy association ditropan tabletki 5 mg 30 szt generic betnovate india nexium in mexico buy requip 10 lamisil looking for viagra equivalent co uk sildenafil citrate tablets buy generic xenical india side effects of atorvastatin and fenofibrate tablets order erythromycin topical dosage what is stromectol made of avodart without script best pharmacy to order feldene singulair paediatric 4mg very cheap aricept generic cystone for sale on line buy moduretic no prescription fast delivery prescription solutions prior auth forms worldwide pharmacy tinidazole is aspirin available in india buy mestinon online reviews zantac coupons printable cleocin shelf life alesse coupon code buy meridia vermox 100mg oral suspension legal to buy cephalexin abc pharmacy san francisco puerto rico elimite cream prices cheap genuine phexin online lasuna mg buy l-tryptophan uk next day delivery 150 viagra aleve perth australia tesco pharmacy online malarone buy naprosyn tablets usa what is the drug antivert for how to make powerful viagra at home using fruits - youtube buy cialis soft in singapore nizagara online from uk methotrexate pills dosage amoxil pills online in the australia wellbutrin discount coupon propranolol beta blockers for anxiety fosamax alternatives men doxycycline treatment leptospirosis dogs amitriptyline costochondritis ampicillin india pharmacy long time side effects fucidin aciclovir australia companies only cheap premarin buy online voltaren overnight order motrin online in usa buy zofran odt canada hyzaar order in the us tadalafil quick delivery lithium reviews for men cheap calan blanes holiday pharmacy online alli prescriptions actos medication calan drug class nitroglycerin in the uk overnight viagra delivery us keflex shoppers drug mart natural selection 2 lerk can you get omnicef children motrin shortage birth control pills avalide capoten dosage forms buy cheap prograf using pay pal no prescription viagra sublingual sale buy ventolin in canada what is compazine made of tamoxifen dose for gynecomastia purchase crestor 5 mg motrin dose for adults buy colchicine 1.2mg no prescription flomax barato viagra price uk boots best place buy norvasc best price for real lynoral best prices pharmacy precose online buy acticin online overnight possession of prescription drugs indiana long time side effects zantac celebrex commercial location bike buy femara in ireland flonase generico italiano safe lithium buy is caverta legal in uk med cab fluoxetine shuddha guggulu cheap uk buy hyzaar with paypal herbal treatment erectile dysfunction australia where is lasix metabolized albendazole not generic homeopathic treatment for arthritis in fingers iv methylprednisolone side effects asthma medication non prescription purchase generic trental allie brosh book fluoxetine from walmart canadian online pharmacy for betapace tamsulosin hydrochloride spc medrol 4mg dose pack dosage order diclofenac potassium approach generic viagra online pharmacy blog zetia ordering online pharmacy costco pharmacy benicar price get zebeta toronto stromectol on line no script list of tesco stores selling dulcolax toradol mg price aldactone drug canadian pharmacy is it safe to order lopid is generic acticin available in usa how fast does alli diet pill work can you get high off snorting trazodone metoclopramide hydrochloride dose cialis buy online us how to take levitra super active side effects of avodart and flomax micardis hct discount top generic drug sales fincar buy on line order florinef 0.1 mg is mail order ralista safe aciclovir discount overnight buy canada no prescription for isoptin proscar tablet sale lasuna prix en pharmacie en france cheap viagra without prescriptions lowest what is metformin pills used for avapro order speman cost canadian acai berry juice australia where to buy genuine prinivil best price buy nitroglycerin with no rx what does adalat xl do where cane i buy tetracycline robaxin on line in the mexico stromectol tablets for purchase where to buy herbal viagra in ireland nitrofurantoin tablets from buy us online pharmacy no prescription ophthacare differin drug in mexico pharmacy xeloda without prescription miami anafranil without rx revista tu online 2011 kamagra uk boots urispas online pay paypal best price viagra professional how to order viramune cheap revia 100 mg pyridium 10 mg cost ebay viagra uk arimidex steroid reviews floxin for sale philippines buy unisom pills online best place to buy live freshwater fish online buy ophthacare with paypal where to buy viagra in toronto methylprednisolone tablets to buy what does vc mean in phenergan vc side effects ordering benzaclin imuran over counter uk legitimate online pharmacy for cialis flomax price walgreens alli orlistat cheap indian pharmacy prograf cheapest erythromycin tablets uk buy antivert for daily use buying cephalexin online herbal medicine for lower back pain perrigo tretinoin cream 0.1 revatio oral suspension prilosec 10 mg packet motrin usa sale unisom cheap us pharmacy colchicine in india i pill wellbutrin sr website pharmacy prescription viagra 100mg buy online avodart now co uk online canadian pharmacy vipps otc zofran discount lamictal cheap valtrex prescription what type of medication is augmentin allie brosh reddit 2012 viagra 50 mg von pfizer amitriptyline generico italiano donde comprar midamor generic aricept buy canada acai prescription coupon nizoral in italia purchase xenical pills cytotec 100 effective generic pills for trazodone cheap mens nike air max 95 trainers where to buy benadryl quick dissolve strips buy femcare tablets online blopress medicine children atarax comprimidos embarazo golden root herbal viagra review cat costa diclofenac gel prednisone medicine children prescription online doctor canada yasmin tablets purchase on line micardis uk online aldactone for sale usa betoptic italiano colchicine canada sale research grade beconase aq zenegra 100 mg can i order nitroglycerin online buy differin from india motrin no prescription needed buy cialis professional online mexico no prescription seroquel 25mg tablet vasotec contraindications andy shaw + canadian healthcare technology

Film Review: Contradiction


In Contradiction, Jeremiah Camara’s intelligent film about religion’s seduction of African-Americans, Lawrence Krauss says “the rise of non-belief is the rise of science.”

Krauss refers of course to natural sciences like cosmology and evolutionary biology, disciplines now giving us empirically based theories for the origin of the universe and man; and to social sciences like sociology and psychology, which are now explaining how the brain generates religious beliefs and behaviors. These new scientific discoveries, Camara recognizes, “are clashing with biblical doctrine,” and exposing the contradiction between truth and African-Americans’ irrationality. In the film – to take just one example – we hear the muddled African-American view that god must have created us, that we could not have evolved from “monkeys” because on earth “we still have monkeys.” This illogic is followed by Richard Dawkins’ concise, scientific explanation of the human family tree. 

Contradiction seamlessly mixes this science with history. Camara traces religion’s stranglehold over African-Americans’ reason (today 76% of all African-Americans say they pray daily) to the institution of slavery, when African-Americans either went to church or faced their masters’ wrath. Slaves adopting Christian beliefs and attending Christian churches received special treatment, even if the ‘beliefs’ were dictated by their masters. And Camara nicely documents the similarities and differences between the roles religious belief and churches have served in African-Americans’ lives.

But what makes Camara’s film so special is neither its science nor its history. Rather, Camara’s film is spellbinding because he takes us right into the faces of both believers and non-believers, in a way quite unimaginable if his subjects were white. It’s not that Camara is uncomfortably confrontational: on the contrary, his deep, mellow voice, eloquence and friendly style remind me of Chicago’s Harold Washington, who seemed totally non-threatening but who also, after five minutes’ conversation, made you wonder why other people were laughing at you. As Camara asks African-American believers honest questions they can’t reasonably answer, they respond to Camara with unembarrassed smiles and cheer. Would any white congregation be so willingly cheerful in verbalizing their ignorance and/or stupidity? And, as we hear from the educated nonbelievers in the Black community, would any of their white counterparts be so openly scathing in their criticism of white believers? In our age of political correctness and divisiveness, Camara’s interviewees are refreshingly honest, though this honesty also reflects religion’s successful subversion of African-Americans’ self-critical faculties.

To be clear, while Camara wants to lay open the symptom, his real mission is to finger the cause. Why, compared to other groups, are African-Americans most committed to their faiths? Camara convincingly demonstrates that religion especially affects (and attracts) them because it offers ‘pie in the sky’ to economically struggling people, people who even think more about Jesus’s suffering than Martin Luther King’s suffering. (Yes, Camara is told, King died for African-Americans’ freedom, but it’s Jesus’s blood that will “wash away our sins.”). Prayer is the first line of defense against this suffering. And as for African-Americans’ increasing attendance at the churches flooding their neighborhoods: the mindless fear-inducing sermons of unqualified African-Americans preachers is the premium African-Americans (especially black women) pay for – the “insurance policy” protecting them from eternal damnation and Satan’s lurking presence. (Anton Scalia, take note: a good preacher can allay your fears too). 

In the end, through a variety of other images – especially his hilarious clips depicting the “six types” of African-American preachers – Camara’s film serves as the cultural supplement to Thomas Piketty’s recent book, 
Capital in the Twenty-First Century. Just as Piketty reminds us that capitalism inherently produces inequality and misery, Camara reminds us that in a capitalist society, religion is the opium of a powerless people. In Camara's words, “Extreme poverty and extreme religiousness go hand in hand ... and dependence of supernatural intervention has become a way of life in African American communities,” where African-Americans pastors encourage parishioners to abandon self-sufficiency and instead rely on divine miracles to improve their lives. To those who criticize our “culture of dependency,” Camara clearly lays the blame at the feet of the African-Americans churches. Yet, herein lies my only disappointment with the film: in Chicago, African American ministers have a well-publicized, cozy relationship with the Mayor’s office. To what degree do African-Americans churches – and the poorly schooled ministers who rule them – serve the larger political and economic interests of the capitalist system and America’s ruling class? A big question perhaps beyond the scope of this film, but I hoped Camara would at least suggest an answer.

Contradiction presents already familiar arguments, you should still treat yourself to the experience. My top 7 not-to-be missed scenes (in no particular order): 
1. Martin Luther King III’s pathetic response when Camara asks if the hours African-Americans spend in churches inhibit their productivity; 
2. from “A Raisin in the Sun”: the scene illustrating Graydon Square’s assertion that to African-American children, god is “the big black woman with a belt”; 
3. Norm Allen’s matter-of-fact observations on the inverse relationship between education and religious belief;
4. Dan Barker’s portrayal of slave submission and its similarities to prayer, as well as his funny piano rendition of “Poor Little Me”;
5. Camara’s short but touching interview with Brooklyn pastor Phyllis Brown, who candidly admits her altruism is about love for her people, and is not contingent upon her attending any church;
6. The nonplussed responses of churchgoers to Camara’s simple question: What did you learn in church today?;
and 7. his interviews with hip-hop singer Graydon Square, whose sharp, right-on the-money commentaries are alone worth the price of admission. (A sample: “[At church, pastors tell blacks that] if they don’t believe in my particular skydaddy, then you’re not gonna get free ice cream…tell that to people in Nigeria, in Liberia, to people in certain parts of South America.”)

Contradiction should not be seen merely by atheists. Children should also have the opportunity to view it. In fact, if I were emperor, I would mandate that every grade school child see it in order to understand the social and political conditions which foster humanity’s irrational addiction to religion. That wish is itself pie-in-the-sky, but for his hard work and intelligence, I thank Jeremiah Camara for providing me with a first-rate teaching resource.


AAI News Team's guest writer is Mark Kolsen, Managing Editor of the Richard Dawkins Foundation Newsletter