can youtube buy levitra super active in ireland cialis buy buspar australia where is artane in ireland non prescription dutas pharmacy buying rogaine 5 in manchester fincar online australia purchase zocor online liquid allegra review cheap levitra plus free delivery keflex usa sale where can i purchase lexapro ordering protonix online is allegra over the counter drugs champix forum 2012 lithium orotate free shipping generic drug review for ajanta pharma online overnight buy lotrisone cod pomegranate juice concentrate suppliers ordering nymphomax here in canada misoprostol in qatar cheap voveran usa ordering silagra how long does levitra last is it illegal to order generic methotrexate advair diskus roche precio argentina rosuvastatin from usa keflex weight gain ordering levitra super active generic online pill store over the counter inhalers for copd citalopram hbr side effects weight gain bromocriptine dosage for infertility fucidin h cream best viagra tablets in india generic for levitra where can i get some rumalaya forte buy cialis sublingual boots pharmacy buy acivir pills free perscription side effects of citalopram hydrobromide buyers of torsemide canada order zovirax on line india discount canadian pharmacy proventil what is cozaar taken for what do hydrochlorothiazide pills look like buy generic tadapox online buy azulfidine pills online cipro fast usa requip paypal very cheap prinivil average dose of celexa for anxiety is levaquin available generic cialis packungseinheiten suhagra prices at costco where can i get doxazosin pills nootropil comprare atorlip-10 uk buy zanaflex for sale philippines order zocor tablets interactions between prednisone and alcohol prednisone effects on blood sugar levels can you buy online uk get antibiotics vantin non perscription countries where to buy nizoral 1 order bentyl canada what is hyzaar used for pfizer cleocin capsules yagara lawsuit settlements mail order prescription drugs no prescription where can you buy female viagra online albendazole india overnight prescription aciphex fedex where to buy citalopram online celexa without compare prices didronel can buy emsam online order allegra d emsam pharmacy buy atrovent paypal accepted grifulvin v micr 500 mg buy erection packs 1 antibiotic zyvox side effects cefadroxil tablets ip 500mg periactin 4mg side effects who makes the best pomegranate juice where amaryl patients diabetes mellitus india viagra pharmaceutical companies cheap viagra jelly approved fda himplasia pas cher purchase keftab lowest price buy azulfidine capsules liquid tamoxifen citrate dosage pct zyrtec vs allegra reviews levothroid medicine price order pariet in buy lamictal online no prescription flagyl dosage for c diff buy motilium tablets uk buspar medication guide etodolac 500 mg dosage can you drink after taking antibiotics for chlamydia buy avodart cheap all rights reserved buy brand micardis high blood pressure medication on the internet insulin overdose fatal prednisone withdrawal order relafen online uk veterinary prednisone dosage purchase generic coumadin elimite supplier in uk diclofenac sodium gel formulation where can i buy effexor xr online without a prescription purchase flomax in australia lopressor order by phone cytoxan mail order diltiazem cost without insurance is alli being discontinued what does ginseng look like in october neurontin 600 mg tablet effexor tablets online zestril usa pharmacy cheap serpina buy online wellbutrin sr medication on line where is bora bora resort located purinethol without prescription comprar isoptin pela internet buy lady era patch trial erection packs 2 online pharmacy purchase generic mobic cialis tablets for sale uk cheapest proscar tablets uses buy endep mexican pharmacies celebrex withdrawal uk zoloft without depression where can i order zithromax how old do you have to be to buy alli diet pills can taking too much synthroid cause weight gain over the counter canada buy lamisil order cheap buy bystolic nebivolol can you order cardizem female viagra pill shop discount code how to use acai berry juice to lose weight billig atorlip-10 online kaufen bentyl pill picture generic kamagra soft tabs periactin uk buy diovan now generic cephalexin dose for cats compare cost of viagra cialis cheapest xeloda to buy is celebrex available in australia what is l-tryptophan found in lov cost pulmicort bactroban nasal ointment for mrsa the online drugstore aygestin comprar erexor portugal myambutol generico italiano propecia dosage 1mg vs 5mg nizagara pills review luvox discounts codes zoloft vs prozac weight gain pletal 50mg tablets can i make zyrtec buy forzest 100mg online best place buy bactrim pct propecia reviews 2010 side effects of trandate labetalol order differin 0.4 india pharmacies online that sell ventolin low cost toradol vantin no rx haridra prix en pharmacie en france minipress 50mg tablets acheter lipitor pas cher generic omnicef paypal no prescription tadacip hydrochlorothiazide pharmacy danazol 200 mg price exelon company philadelphia alli weight loss tablets can you get antibiotics over the counter in spain canadian online pharmacy for caverta free sample of viraga vermox from china generic cialis good brand donde comprar alesse can you take depakote daily bactrim ds side effects rash liposafe canada head office can imuran cause weight gain cost of over the counter zyrtec diamox no prescription reviews cafergot drug albendazole without a prescription from india how often can i take 20 mg of cialis? coreg no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy order zebeta from canada without prescription celexa side effects in men order lopressor online with visa noroxin pill shop discount code minomycin for sale ordering duphalac farmacia online portugal cialis buy doxycycline hyclate uk nifedipine side effects pregnancy periactin mg usa is there a generic for prilosec kamagra oral jelly online pharmacy when does the drug diovan go generic new mexico alliance of health councils diflucan by mail prescription zoloft canada buy allegra d from canada luvox 100 review buy orlistat 100mg online tadalafil india cong dung cua thuoc medrol 16mg prograf in usa no prescription plavix sale is dapoxetine legal in the uk what is phenergan dm used for procardia heart medicine where to buy cheap generic midamor buy minocycline online canada no prescription diflucan otc walgreens order femara cheap buy offers tetracycline buy actos prescription pioglitazone hydrea for men sale in uk ginseng canada prescription fosamax order generic uk paypal remeron best place to buy nimotop generic alesse 21 contraceptive evecare rx abilify over the counter paypal overseas best online viagra from canada discount epivir-hbv walmart generic drug list and cost commander viagra en ligne cialis sublingual online pharmacy buy propecia 200 what is the medication procardia used for azithromycin 250 mg to treat chlamydia grifulvin v reviews for men is it safe to order reglan buy prilosec tablets online Purchase accutane 30 mg online buy methocarbamol dogs order non generic lipitor medrol online meds resources for living januvia sales in india 2010 order retin a online tamoxifen tablets 150 mg reviews on mobicool overseas pharmacy no prescription buspar neurontin dose for diabetic neuropathy safe buy antivert online roxithromycin india ralista for men in usa what is diclofenac diethylammonium gel tofranil without prescription miami fluoxetine not generic online pharmacy uk calan atacand plus generic one man one jar official video which are common side effects of nitroglycerin (select all that apply.) mechanism of action of danazol in itp clozaril canada prescription child benadryl dose diovan now united pharmacies uk md purchasing tenormin online uk detrol discount coupon viagara online vipps pay with paypal account augmentin side effects uk female cialis where to purchase acivir pills online uk avalide 10 mg cost sustiva prescription only maximum coreg dose overseas pharmacy no prescription zetia cheapest place to buy zyrtec prescription asacol discontinued warner chilcott benadryl generico shatavari india paroxetine in usa zyvox sales 2009 differin on line for sale no script content validity example buy purim australia zantac shoppers drug mart best price for celebrex generic estradiol hemihydrate bioidentical where to buy tinidazole with visa online pharmacy no prescription needed vermox orlistat next day shipping xeloda in croatia what does biaxin cure malegra fxt echeck dipyridamole dose titration diclofenac sodium gel formula metformin over the couter cheap kamagra pills guaranteed cleocin dosage for dogs which uk site to buy triamterene buy sinemet 40 brand name wellbutrin prices pediatric zithromax dose chart para que sirve el vytorin 10 40 mg topamax daily use reviews safe place order nizoral nizoral online pay paypal acai berry fruit where to buy in uk rabeprazole sodium 20 mg side effects what is sildenafil citrate 100mg pills generic viagra order viagra the little blue pill with big repercussions allopurinol over the counter prescription price viagra 150 mg nombre comercial furosemida mexico www online pharmacy solutions com betnovate rd cream steroid kenalog and lidocaine injection trileptal generic for clomid pas cher renew prescription without doctor visit paxil generic form diovan discount coupon ponstel tablets order generic lariam minocin pill shop discount code perception medacion without perception bactrim 100mg generic coreg switzerland cytoxan 25 mg tabletta viagra for sale no prescription lowest buy dramamine 10 without a script buy diamox mg buy metformin paypal buy proscar greece sale kamagra soft xanax online uk alli reviews 2011 acheter levitra plus pas cher coming off of depakote buy tamoxifen online in usa buy aciclovir from india vermox tablets uses buy risperdal greece buy over the counter micronase online cost of lipothin order indocin overnight legal buy ephedraxin online canada fertomid 100mg success stories menosan overnight pharmacy purchase generic ralista order reglan no rx canadian pharmacy flagyl er 10 mg cost ringworm medication otc purchase cortef online urgent delivery viagra otc canada cheapest online generic albendazole buy diltiazem paypal accepted can you get zestoretic over the counter buy birth control pill canada cost of imuran fincar buy canada side effects of misoprostol tablets how much does flovent cost without insurance promethazine w/codeine syrup prices canadian hoodia tablet finpecia buy online uk how many doses of prednisolone for croup buy vpxl with e check eurax suppositories buy how to buy clomid online australia delivery order diclofenac online order ditropan medication by mail is generic colchicine available in usa ordering glucophage online metformin vermox no prrescription overnight pharmacy does alli work pills long term side effects of kamagra soft zetia cost in canada colchicine brand positioning canadian pharmacy levitra birth control pills celexa statue to meridia long time side effects cialis allegra rx to otc switch is it ok to mix prednisone and alcohol intravenous antibiotics for uti order ashwagandha canada inr warfarin como debo tomar el cytotec para abortar canadian online pharmacy for rumalaya forte cefadroxil order in the us forum cheap allegra online sneezing didronel order in the us crestor overseas statin drugs side effects erectile dysfunction is vyvanse better than strattera where purchase flonase rogaine 5 sale acai costa rica acnur what is tramadol for pain retino-a cream 0,05 order online amoxil how to buy mexico avapro cialis jelly tablets side effects erythromycin ethylsuccinate uses pharmacy that sells midamor buy drugs from india online tadalafil 5mg benadryl plus capsules dose watch antiviral full movie online free can buy zenegra online best drugstore foundation for summer 2012 what is the drug mobic used for gout flare up while allopurinol buy xanax online no prescription overnight erythromycin oral acne side effects what is the difference between claritin and claritin d side effects of long term use of dramamine xenical tablets for weight loss skelaxin 800 mg max dose purchase metformin cheap chloromycetin dosage too high generic avodart canada walmart zetia price prevacid dosage forms fml forte coupon code cheapest actos available where to buy kamagra jelly viagra cialis or levitra which is best alavert price comparison ultra low dose snovitra super power where can i buy amitriptyline online no prescription needed common side effects of methotrexate best viagra professional prices online drug where does ginseng grow in canada buy prilosec in bulk does generic buspar look like dramamine india what does ginseng smell like print alli coupon online online pharmacy canada azithromycin 500mg for gonorrhea purchase generic cystone generic rumalaya benzac gel costo generic drug sales 2012 cost of beconase aq buy cabana cheap drugstore best online pharmacy tech school prescription viagra super active buying phenamax provera discount medications viagra bologna how to buy lincocin in canada lisinopril hctz user reviews Purchase abilify 4mg online clomid ovulation test negative cafergot online pay paypal coversyl side effects alcohol kroger pharmacy drug prices viagra phone orders what is fucidin h cream used to treat buy tadalis sx patch clonidine dose for agitation cytotec abortion pills dosage compazine medication where to buy prescription needed buy carafate generic brand advair diskus overnite shipping finax tablet sale viagra super active 40mg allegra com srbija kamagra pills online in the canada buy keftab patch prometh with codeine cough syrup online canada kamagra what is the dosage for dulcolax what does bystolic look like acquistare silagra in italia buy zoloft online buy synthroid without prescription buy generic viagra in the united states wellbutrin weight gain women accutane dose bentyl pill shortage buy desyrel canadian cheapest avodart to buy benicar tablets price hoodia pills in india buy artane online no prescription us billig brand levitra online kaufen can you buy viagra soft in ireland cheap prices digoxin first order kinetics skelaxin without a prescription bactrim no prescription reviews how much does arimidex cost in the uk aciclovir crema 50mg/g viagra vs cialis information buy brand advair diskus online at canada pharmacy get viagra today where can i buy brand amoxil cheap clomid 40 mg plavix tablets online fast strattera deleviery mail order generic rogaine 2 cialis for men with erectile dysfunction is it illegal to order generic dutas side effects of drinking alcohol while taking doxycycline alli over the counter canada prevacid over the counter strength how to get brand levitra drug levlen coming off buy paxil without prescription amoxicillin dosage for cats ephedraxin 5mg tablets solebox adidas torsion allegra for sale buy myambutol uk buy clonidine online reviews aciphex annual sales acheter crestor pas cher purchase fucidin online no prescription what is altace hct overseas pharmacy no prescription tulasi side effects of methotrexate for arthritis prevacid solutab rxlist canadian pharmacy clozaril haldol lawsuit erexin-v drug class is lithium available over the counter where to buy real cialis pilex australia pharmacy better than reglan cheapest suhagra tablets uk nitroglycerin online uk azithromycin tablets dosage for children buy colospa bulk canadian online medicine viagra pill generic zyvox buy cheap femara letrozole side effects reviews on malegra fxt association deans pharmacy canada where lanoxin online pharmacy degree college extendaquin paypal prescription motrin dosage to buy meclizine how does accutane work to cure acne side effects of valacyclovir hcl bupropion drugs forum pharmacy price checker usa brand levitra sale generic online pill store is 100mg of viagra too much viagra tesco stores sell contraindication of ranitidine medicine cheap bystolic india what does depakote er do protonix pill shop discount code lioresal roche precio argentina buy kamagra jelly paypal chloromycetin redidrops 0.5 citalopram from usa do i need a prescription for cialis jelly order cozaar buy drugs from canada no prescriptions promethazine overdose mg generic from eulexin ampicillin drug action yasmin pharmacy lexapro generic release date 2012 problems with fosamax medication how to buy xeloda in london how much does alli cost rx health reviews drugstore net index cefixime side effects uk can order luvox online cost of calcium carbonate medco mail order pharmacy site nome generico do cipro kytril in croatia isotretinoin generic is mail order serpina safe phexin australia pharmacy abilify shipping overseas purchase flagyl cream cytoxan reviews amaryl drug information claritin eye drops purchase fucidin medicine best site to buy famvir proventil 40 mg dose buy roaccutane roche pastillas anticonceptivas yasmin precio en mexico aldactone overnight delivery do you gain weight after going off topamax buy citalopram mg how to take diflucan 150 mg how much does seroquel cost without insurance claritin brands india where can i buy parlodel information on plavix tablets depo medrol pills for dogs para que se usa cipro get mentat las vegas other drugs that work like viagra where can i get some periactin cheapest beconase aq tablets uk prednisona dosis oral stats hell regression order fucidin online canada buy tadapox with paypal renagel cheap price co diovan weight gain costco leicester closing times fast aleve delivery acai mail order how to use zithromax for stds fluoxetine buy mexico florida phexin ventolin coupon 2013 innopran xl discount voucher motilium 10 mg film-coated tablets korean ginseng 1000 mg avalide class action lawsuit what do abilify pills look like compare prices aldactone cost of prilosec prescription top canadian drug companies buy zoloft online with mastercard non prescription diltiazem torsemide on line crestor no prescription reviews betapace dosage too high tamoxifen pct cycle can i buy with paypal without credit card female cialis for men in usa house calls pharmacy warrensburg cheap diflucan pills how much is fluoxetine without insurance does triamterene cause kidney stones purchasing zovirax online can you buy 30 mg prevacid over counter buy canada no prescription for imitrex buying xenical for dogs colospa shoppers drug mart alli comprar espan~a phenergan cost comparison discount nexium generic substitute where to buy amaryllis belladonna keflex ordering online cabgolin cost in canada provera 10mg for 10 days side effects inderal over counter substitute silagra online meds where to buy childrens motrin pastillas cytotec como usarlas xenical shortage roche discount canadian pharmacy serevent black cobra 120 robaxin dose frequency celexa canadian pharmacy what is the dosage of tinidazole ordering adalat here in canada doxycycline dose for malaria treatment buy effexor xr with online pharmacy
 
 

Religion as a human rights liability

NIDA KIRMANI 16 April 2014, Open Democracy

Although many human rights movements have religious underpinnings, explicitly linking religion to human rights can lead to the exclusion and persecution of minority groups. To protect the rights of those minorities, we must work to keep religion separate from human rights. 

Pakistani Hazara community known as Shiite community hold placards as they take part in a rally on January 22, 2014, in Islamabad, Pakistan, Sajjad Ali Qureshi/Demotix. All Rights Reserved.

 It is no secret that many human rights have an inherently religious dimension, as Larry Cox recently argued on openGlobalRights. But do religion and human rights really need each other, as he suggests? While many of history’s greatest human rights movements have been inspired by religious ideals of justice and equality, the explicit linking of religion and human rights can be highly problematic for particular people groups, especially women and sexual and religious minorities.

 

Although Cox argues that faith-based action is an important force in undermining repressive political regimes, women’s movements in the Indian and Pakistani contexts have generally operated from a secular platform, arguing for a clear distinction between religion and matters of the state. In fact, women’s movements in both countries are acutely aware of the dangers of combining religion and government, precisely because the interpretations adopted usually favor the interests of powerful (male) groups.  In India, an officially secular state, religious pluralism provides a separate set of family laws for each religious “community,” an approach that is itself problematic because it denies the complexity, divisions, and hierarchy within religious communities.  In the case of Muslim personal law, women are at a particular disadvantage in matters related to divorce and maintenance. For sexual minorities, the recent reinstatement of Section 377, which essentially criminalizes homosexuality, was at least partially due to pressure from religious conservative groups, who came together in a rare case of multi-religious cooperation.

In the Pakistani context, where Islam is the official state religion, a host of religiously justified laws were introduced under the regime of Zia-ul-Haq. These laws included the Hudood Ordinances, which made it nearly impossible for women to prove a rape in court without the testimony of four male witnesses. Also included was the Law of Evidence, which reduced the testimony of all women and non-Muslim men to half that of a Muslim man.  While the Hudood Ordinances have since been somewhat reformed, women’s rights continue to stand on shaky ground largely because religious conservative groups have significant lawmaking power.  For example, despite years of struggle, theDomestic Violence Bill has not been passed because some religious groups see it as an assault on their conception of the family.  Even less progress has been made in terms of sexual minority rights in Pakistan, as no LGBT movement has yet emerged.  In fact, in June 2011, as an indication of what such a movement would incite, several religious groups vocally protested the US embassy’s “gay pride” event as an attack of “cultural terrorism.”

The amalgamation of religion and the state has also been extremely detrimental to religious minority groups in both India and Pakistan.  In India, the rise of the Hindu Right, which views India as an essentially Hindu nation, has had exceptionally negative consequences for members of minority communities, including Muslims and Christians. This movement has led to horrific episodes of communal violence, from the riots across India in 1992-1993 following the destruction of the Babri Masjid, to the pogroms in Gujarat against Muslims in 2002, to the violent clashes in Muzaffarnagar in August and September 2013. 

In Pakistan, the blending of religion with the nation-state has had even more explicit negative consequences for members of religious minority groups.  The official identification of the Pakistani state as ‘Islamic’ in 1949 has led to all non-Muslims being automatically given second-class status as citizens.  This political marginalization has also provided tacit justification for countless episodes of violence against religious minority communities.  Because blasphemy is a crime punishable by death, Christians have been attacked both as individuals and as a community, with entire neighborhoods, such as Badami Bagh in Lahore, being burned to the ground.  Both the state and Islamic groups have also developed a progressively narrow definition of “Muslim,” which began with the Ahmadi community being legally declared “non-Muslim” in 1974.  This quest to define the “true Muslim” has led to a steady increase in sectarian violence across the country.  The targeted killings of Shia professionals across the country, and the attacks on the Hazara community in Quetta, are some of the worst examples of such violence in recent years.

In both the Indian and Pakistani contexts, then, the dangers of not taking a secular approach to human rights are all too clear. Cox argues that human rights movements should harness the power of religion in order to build support.  Yet the question remains, which religion will be harnessed and whose version of that religion will be preferred? In multi-religious societies, an explicit use of religion as a mobilizing force means the exclusion of minority religious communities, as well as a denial of internal hierarchies and tensions within religious communities.  In India, where Hindus are the majority, any attempt by the women’s movement to use Hindu religious symbols, such as the goddess Kali, has alienated non-Hindu women.  In Pakistan, where Muslims are the vast majority, an appeal to Islamic ideas of justice and equality also means an exclusion of women from minority communities.

While one cannot deny that ideas about dignity, equality, and justice are enshrined in all of the world’s religions, the interpretation of these terms differs greatly amongst and within religious traditions.  In addition, all of the world’s religions contain strands that are clearly unsupportive of human rights. Even the most progressive interpretations of most major religions eventually hit a brick wall with certain rights, particularly regarding gender and sexuality.  Therefore, while it is tempting to pick and choose aspects of religion that support human rights, the complications and risks that arise from doing so are simply too great.

At the same time, we should not ignore the importance of religion as a motivating force to achieve human rights, and we should not deny people the right to express their religious beliefs, provided that such expression does not also deny the rights of others.  However, there is a difference between being personally motivated by religion, which can be a powerful driver, and religiously identifying as a movement, which can exclude non-believers and provide space for more fundamentalist religious interpretations to thrive.

 

For human rights activists, it is important to remember that protection of human rights is the bottom line.  Bringing religion back into human rights can be appealing, particularly at a time when the human rights movement seems to be lacking “soul” as Cox implies, but including religion in the debate is also dangerous.  For women and other minorities, it can quite literally become a matter of life and death.